The Best restaurants in City Island

Map view

Explore the best places in City Island and discover hidden gems, top-rated spots, most reviewed destinations, and recently added venues. Let us guide you through City Island's culinary delights and vibrant scene. Ratings are based from 6 places in City Island.

Sort results by:

6 results

Best Top rated Most reviewed Hidden gems Worst rated Recently updated

Artie's Steak & Seafood

4.6 ( 50 )

394 City Island Ave 10464-1323

"Amazing food! I loved the Fettuccine with shrimp and lobster. The plates are big. The staff was very friendly. The bathroom was very clean and the food and drinks were delicious. This is a very nice..."

Menu online

Clipper Coffee

4.9 ( 39 )

274 City Island Ave 10464-1431

"Great local coffee shop with a deep menu of coffee and food, comfortable seating, work from local artists on display, friendly service and reasonable prices. Highly recommended if you're visiting City..."

Scavello's On The Island

4.5

101 City Island Ave 10464-1616

The Lobster Box

4.4 ( 50 )

34 City Island Ave 10464-1609

"This was a nice spot. We ate and watched the SUN set. The waiter was very attentive and funny. Food was out pretty quickly.. It was REALLY GOOD TASTY.. The shrimp was really delicious.."

Jp's City Island

3.5

703 Minnieford Ave 10464-1123

Filomena's Pizza

4.6 ( 50 )

288 City Island Ave 10464-1433

"The food vibes let you feel like you on the island"