Sign in
Hidden gems: restaurants in Buffalo
Map viewDiscover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Buffalo. Ratings are based from 895 places in Buffalo
Dinosaur Bar-B-Que
301 Franklin St 14202-1901
"Great BBQ place located in the downtown area of Buffalo. All the standard items of BBQ are available here - ribs, pulled pork, chicken wings, brisket, mac and cheese... You can't go wrong with any foo..."
Osteria 166
166 Franklin St 14202-2407
"We went for early dinner, seated in the front where bar is, nice atmosphere. Good menu selection and a bit unique, I had the Wild Board Parpadelle, it was excellent, found the grapes interesting and u..."
Toutant
437 Ellicott St 14203-1519
"Truly a gem in the city. Eating here is a privilege and the drinks are just as delectable."
Allen Burger Venture
175 Allen St 14201-1515
"Rustic ambience with superb service and divine flavors. Killer craft beer on tap and review worthy burgers.Ate a jiffy #5 then a smothered colorado #7. Do not miss out on this joint!"
Santasiero's Restaurant
1329 Niagara St 14213-1306
"Delicious! I've been hearing about this place for a long time & finally got a chance to try it! I knew I wouldn't be near a fridge for awhile, no way to store left overs, so I ordered small/side porti..."
Gene McCarthy's
73 Hamburg St 14204-2719
"Good lunch spot. Consistently good food and beer and they are able to serve large parties."
Spot Coffee
50 Fountain Plz 14202-2230
"Walk in and enjoy the delightful aroma of coffee and breakfast food. Sip coffee sitting inside at tables or comfy sofas. Take your food to outside sidewalk tables with umbrellas. Check out their roast..."
Parkside Meadow
2 Russell St 14214-1930
"I really like their location. Every time I go to the Buffalo zoo I go here to grab some lunch. This is the nearest restaurant near the zoo. It’s just opposite to the zoo. I really like their ambianc..."
Hydraulic Hearth Restaurant & Brewery
716 Swan St 14210-1058
"Hydraulic hearth is so good, I feel like I’m cheating on the restaurant if I eat out at another spot while in town. They have really inventive events like one I went to in the summer was Luau themed..."
Cafe 59
62 Allen St 14202-1321
"We've eaten here since they were across the street in humbler digs and we keep coming back. Where else can you find a menu that works for anyone with quirks in their diet or not. Amazing salads and wr..."
India Gate
1116 Elmwood Ave Ste A 14222-1200
"This is our go-to take out during quarantine hands down!! We drive 30 minutes to pick it up and they never disappoint. Definitely worth trying, especially if you’re new to Indian cuisine."
Marco's Italian Restaurant
1085 Niagara St 14213-2008
"Recently ordered Fish Fry on a Friday for my very first visit. Not many places near me open for fish fry due to the Corona virus. Friend had the chicken Jimmy. That order was huge as was the fish fry..."
Colter Bay Grill
561 Delaware Ave 14202-1201
"Wonderful experience. They have an extensive tap list for the inner beer nerd. And all the food sounded so good I had a really hard time deciding. I loved my beat salad but the sweet potato fries were..."
Bob & John's La Hacienda
1545 Hertel Ave 14216-2805
"I would highly recommend that you go to Bob’s. He knows how to take care of his customers and is always up for a pleasant conversation while doing his business. This place has a warm aura, amazing j..."
Apollo Family Restaurant
3387 S Park Ave 14219-1029
"Great place to eat. The servers are attentive, kind, and good at their jobs. The food is priced well, it comes out quick, and it tastes good. Can't go wrong. My only criticism is that it's a cash only..."
Mythos Restaurant
510 Elmwood Ave 14222-2014
"If you're looking for the best authentic Greek restaurant - look no further. Everything I've ever ordered is DELICIOUS. Even though it's known for its brunch, the dinner is underrated (the lambchops a..."
Allen Street Poutine Company
242 Allen St 14201-1324
"Enjoyed the atmosphere of this place. Got to write on the brick wall with markers. The poutines were pretty yummy."
Prima Pizza Pasta
396 Pearl St Corner of Chippewa St 14202-2202
"I planned on ordering the chicken parm but the pizza looked really good so I went with that instead. Crust is doughy and softer than I'm used to but very good. Plenty of upstairs seating if you don't..."
The Olive Branch Family Restaurant
2343 Union Rd 14224-1447
"First time here. We arrived just before large groups came in. We were seated right away. Server was pleasant and brought us coffee right away. Breakfast menu has quite an assortment of options. There..."
Public Espresso + Coffee
391 Washington St 14203-2108
"Just spoke to the owner (Steve Jobs look-a-like) to say how good the breakfast was. Coffee pour-over decaf was fantastic, Americano was great and the breakfast plate and hash bowls were really good. V..."