Sign in
The Best restaurants in Sayville
Map viewExplore the best places in Sayville and discover hidden gems, top-rated spots, most reviewed destinations, and recently added venues. Let us guide you through Sayville's culinary delights and vibrant scene. Ratings are based from 38 places in Sayville.
Butera's
100 S Main St 11782-3100
"We've been here quite a few times and don't have any complaints. We were just there for my son's college graduation dinner. This restaurant is labeled as family style because of the portions, not beca..."
Sayville Pizza
60 Main St 11782-2504
"This restaurant is my favored. I go to a lot of restaurants but to this restaurant I constantly return again and again. The stuff is very professional and the cuisine they place on your table is so f..."
Subway
186 W Main St Unit 2 11782-2528
"Nice atmosphere and very personal service. The meals were crisp and delightful. Will surely recommend this spot to friends and family. Affordable prices and large meals. Keep it up."
Parlor House Grill
298 W Main St 11782-2526
"I arrive at this special restaurant once a month because I enjoy the special air that is outline this place. The crew is awfuly attentive and well trained. The service is deeply efficient. Also, the f..."
Aegean Cafe Incorporated
35 Main St 11782-2501
"I can’t say enough good about Aegean Cafe. I wish there was an option to give more stars. We love the food here and dine here multiple times a week. We won’t go to other Greek Restaurants. Thank y..."
Off The Block
501 Montauk Highway corner of Seville Blvd. 11782
"Have been getting curbside takeout with them for weeks now. Organized and friendly. Highly recommend. Food is amazing as always, and it feels good to support a local small business. Until we can dine..."
Sal's Pizza
183 W Main St 11782-2521
"Great pizza. Locally owned and operated by family. Truly a staple in the town of Sayville. Nothing comes close to Sal’s."
Blackbirds Grill
553 Old Montauk Hwy 11782-2520
"Good food and friendly waitstaff! You can go here for a variety of options-beer and a burger, or a more high end delicious meal! I love the stuffed shrimp or gumbo!"
Oversouth Tavern and Grille
209 Railroad Ave 11782-2714
"Good vibe. Welcoming manager and bar staff. Even made food for my kids. My new spot when I’m sick of the typical sayville bars. Food is very very good and not what you would expect from the place th..."
Ralph's Italian Ices
153 Main St 11782-2503
"Sayville Ralph's Italian Ices is a good place to get italian ices and ice cream. Tasty. Prices are okay. High school kids working the counter need to brush up on their people skills though."
Cull House
75 Terry St 11782-3235
"This was exactly what I hoped to find for a dockside dining experience — refreshing cocktails, fresh seafood, and a friendly, casual ambiance. With a live band playing at the bar, we chose to sit in..."