Sign in
Hidden gems: restaurants in New York City
Map viewDiscover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in New York City. Ratings are based from 11866 places in New York City
Ellen's Stardust Diner
1650 Broadway 10019-6833
"After more than one hour waiting in line... Finally we get in. It's really worth it! You don't come here for the fine cuisine but for the entertainment. We really had fun... And our waiter James... My..."
Carmine's Italian Restaurant - Times Square
200 W 44th St Times Square 10036
"It was absolutely manic in there and If you don’t book expect a long wait, however it is 100% worth it. Portion sizes are huge! We shared the Sunday special (consisting of 4 different dishes) betwee..."
Tony's Di Napoli - Midtown
147 W 43rd St 10036-6575
"BEST SPOT TO EAT IN NEW YORK! NO BETTER ITALIAN FOOD IN NEW YORK!!! Blown away by the food and service! We go here every time we visit New York City! If you never been this is a must visit spot if yo..."
burger joint
119 W 56th St Parker New York 10019-4000
"Only in NYC can there exist an unexpected gem like this. Reasonably priced, made to order and perfectly prepared, gourmet burgers are grilled behind a nondescript curtain in a hotel lobby. It is the..."
Le Bernardin
155 W 51st St 10019-6019
"I'm in the mood for some pasta, and I know that this Italian restaurant has it all. The service was good, and the pasta was really exceptional. I am deeply happy that I was able to dine here because t..."
K Rico Steakhouse
772 9th Ave 10019-6327
"We chose K Rico Steakhouse for our anniversary dinner whilst in New York. This was our first time together in the city and K Rico did not disappoint. We were looking for a restaurant with a good selec..."
Olio e Piu
3 Greenwich Ave 10014-3543
"exceptional cheese flavors and cooked perfectly. The waiter recommended two pizzas, but one sufficed. Highly recommend."
Red Rooster Harlem
310 Lenox Avenue 10027-4449
"The place lives up to its name. really nice soul joint by Legend Marcus Samuelson. I even got the pleasure to see him in the restaurant. It could be a little more romantic with the music lowered. for..."
The Halal Guys
6th Avenue At 53rd
"Quick and tasty, is all you need to know!Hand made fresh from the cart, chill drinks to pickup covered with ice, Delicious food. Beef gyro sandwich is just amazing and you can’t match it anywhere el..."
The Lobster Place
75 9th Ave Chelsea Market 10011-7006
"I always go to this place for fresh & tasted they have the most popular type of oysters which you could choose. What I chose is the oyster platter, definitely the great value and quality. They neve..."
Rosie O'Grady's
800 7th Ave 10019-5810
"good NY place, maybe a tourist trap but nice place with good food. great service and attention to details, kept our waters filled."
Magnolia Bakery
1240 Avenue of the Americas 10020-1522
"One of the best banana bread pudding I had in a long while.The rate was perfect. The consistency was on point. Perfect ratio of bananas in there. Just heavenly and fresh. The literally make the whole..."
Trattoria Dell'Arte
900 7th Ave at 57th Street 10106-0200
"This is a beautiful place for great Italian food!! Their service is impeccable and quick. Good selection of wine and out of this world desserts! Good for an intimate setting or for a group of people...."
Scarlatto
317 West 46 Street Between 8,9 avenues 10036-1414
"Great Italian food. Our server recommended us a bottle of wine and I can say, he has a good taste. It was a very good wine. The atmosphere is great. The place looks nice and cozy. I like to thank Tedd..."
Per Se
10 Columbus Cir 10019-1158
"The best date night of my life!!My husband booked us to have dinner here after we got married at city hall and I have to say, it was the best "date night" of my life. The food was exceptional. The ser..."
Bryant Park Grill
25 W 40th St 10018-2601
"My company had our Christmas party there. It was a wonderful experience! The place was festive and cheery. The service was great and the food and drinks were amazing. I highly recommend this place!"
Los Tacos No. 1
75 9th Ave 10011-7006
"Hands down the best tacos I ever had in NYC! If you don't like spicy food you can ask for "no pepper" (once you place your order, they will give you a paper that you hand to the cooks and they will as..."
Bleecker Street Pizza
69 7th Ave S at Bleecker Street Pizza 10014-4043
"Famous American foods are in this restaurant! Last Sunday, my family and I were having dinner in this place. We felt so happy because the foods were so delicious and mouthwatering. We got home with a..."
The Counter
7 Times Sq 41st & Broadway 10036-6524
"First meal in NYC, and let me tell you, it was the best freaking burger and fries I've ever had. Like, I couldn't stop saying "Oh, my GOD" because it was so delicious. I got the classic cheeseburger w..."
Levain Bakery Harlem
2167 Frederick Douglass Blvd at 117th Street 10026-2040
"I’ve said this once and I’ll say it again! Levain has the best cookies in nyc. Sure you’re gonna pay a small premium, but that’s NYC. There’s lot of other bakeries that charge more and donâ€..."