The Best restaurants in Edgartown
Map viewExplore the best places in Edgartown and discover hidden gems, top-rated spots, most reviewed destinations, and recently added venues. Let us guide you through Edgartown's culinary delights and vibrant scene. Ratings are based from 49 places in Edgartown.
Among The Flowers Cafe
17 Mayhew Ln 02539-8123
19 Raw Oyster Bar
19 Church St 02539-8160
"Excellent experience having our entire meal at the bar outside. Everything was great from the drinks to the food to the service. This place definitely has one of the more creative dinner and cocktail..."
Atria
137 Main St 02539
"Food and service was great. Cocktails were average $15, but they packed a punch. They have three sitting areas (main floor, patio, basement) but both times I came here I only ate in the basement. The..."
Town Bar MV
227 Upper Main St 02539
Katama General Store
170 Katama Rd 02539-8719
"I remember what this place used to be and now it's amazing. It is the perfect place to stop on your way to South Beach. They have everything you could need for the beach and more. I especially like th..."
Myx Market Martha's Vineyard
23 Kelley St 02539-8162
"Best smoothies anywhere on Martha's Vineyard. Also definitely great for the freshest grab-and-go on the island, and very friendly staff."
Seafood Shanty
31 Dock St 02539-8151
"Outstanding! Service was fun and quick, thanks Michael. Busy but we got a table for 8 right away. Everyone’s food was great. Third visit but will come back many times for sure."
Dairy Queen (Treat)
242 Main St 02539-0158
"Only the best in Edgartown hands down !!! Please check it and be sure to tip the awesome staff :)"
The Covington
52 Main St 02539-8237
"We had a great meal, great wine, and great service at The Covington. The interior of the restaurant was lighter and brighter than The Port Hunter across the street and a little quieter. The food at th..."
The Terrace at The Charlotte Inn
27 S Summer St 02539-8115
"Superlative presentation. Highly knowledgeable staff. Excellent food. Questionable decor! Look for the pig."
MacPhail's Corner Cafe
18 Dock St 02539-8152
Back Porch Larder
14 A St Suite 3 02539-6014
Roxana Bar
131 N Water St Harbor View Hotel 02539-8016
The Scoop Shack
22 Dock St 02539-8152
"Nice little ice cream and candy shop. They have all kinds of great candy and classic little toys and tokens. Store has a cool style. Lots of ice cream options too which is great. Crunchy PB, mint Oreo..."
Espresso Love - Martha's Vineyard
17 Church St 02539-8160
"Loved the patio. Had a good chicken salad but didn’t get to try the espresso because it started to rain! Will try the espresso next time around"
China House
234 Upper Main St 02539-5931
"This is your classic conundrum the food is cheap but it is pretty tasty, definitely not a fancy dining place but great for picking up takeout and having it ready in 15 minutes the staff is super frien..."
Square-Rigger Restaurant
225 Vineyard Haven Road 02539-6941
"Food was good. Service excellent"