Sign in
Hidden gems: restaurants in Indianapolis
Map viewDiscover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Indianapolis. Ratings are based from 1953 places in Indianapolis
Long's Bakery
1453 N Tremont St 46222-2800
"I am from the area but moved away years ago, so I hadn't stopped by Long's in a ... well, long time. With restaurants reopening, I decided to stop in for some donuts from my childhood. Aside from the..."
Shapiro's Delicatessen
808 S Meridian St 46225-1335
"My absolute favorite casual restaurant in Indy. Yes it's pricey - but any authentic kosher deli with quality meats piled high are going to charge $15 sandwiches - it's typical! But the food is incredi..."
Cafe Patachou
225 W Washington St 46204-3435
"Tried this place based on a recommendation. It was decent. I had the chicken salad sandwich. It was good but nothing exceptional. They seem to offer a large variety of vegan and gluten free options wh..."
Mesh
725 Massachusetts Ave 46204-1608
"Big thanks to Josh Smith for a great night. Mom was in town from Jersey for her birthday. I took her to Mesh to show her that Indiana was a food and wine destination. Was not disappointed. The dev..."
Maggiano's - Indianapolis
3550 E 86th St 46240-2424
"Delicious! The staff is friendly and the food is tasty. You're able to get your pasta made exactly how you'd like it and the portions are big enough to take some home. They also offer lighter portions..."
Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant
1031 E 54th St 46220-3219
"// A wonderful local business that needs your support during this time! They are open for carry out 7days a week until 8pm and have A perfect pickup system in place. The food is amazing as always. The..."
Slippery Noodle Inn
372 S Meridian St 46225-1193
"Awesome spot! Love blues every night and the group when we were there, on a Monday, with no cover, was incredible. Food is way above what you'd expect in a club. I had an excellent grouper sub- fish w..."
Union 50
620 N East St 46202-3421
"Ok things I liked: great atmosphere, delicious deserts,good customer service. Things I didn’t like: old scallops,too chewy. Coming to Indianapolis from Atlantic Canada, you learn about seafood fresh..."
Tastings A Wine Experience
50 W Washington St 46204-3402
"What a smart idea to have this self served wine tasting bar where you use a card to order your own wine from these cool machines! Great appetizers.. Came here for a party with our company, so fun!"
Greek Islands Restaurant INC
906 S Meridian St 46225-1337
"Very authentic Greek food. Spanakopitas were absolutely tremendous, chicken was deliciously tender, and dessert was fantastic. My family and I will definitely be coming back here. Great community too...."
Bakersfield
334 Massachusetts Ave 46204-2109
"AMAZING Tacos. Stopped for lunch and had drinks and tacos. So Delish! We sat in the basement (21 or over). We will definitely go back!"
Three Sisters Cafe
6223 Guilford Ave 46220-1928
"This spot makes you feel so at home. Great food, fantastic servers and ambiance. Weekend mornings are packed out. I love their specials and espresso drinks. WARNING: Pancakes are HUGE. Start with 1 :)..."
Historic Steer-In Restaurant
5130 E 10th St 46219-4308
"Main thing is customer service. Amazing. They went above and beyond and I really appreciate it. Food was awesome and not expensive. My friend just moved in the neighborhood and I will be ordering from..."
Yats on College
5363 N College Ave 46220-3141
"Awesome food! The prices are great for the portions they give you. The staff is always laid back and nice."
Ale Emporium
8617 Allisonville Rd 46250-1552
"This is the go to place anywhere in Indy for great wings, pizza, and a vast beer selection. Numerous TVs for your viewing pleasure. This is a great place and has been a staple in Indy for a long time...."
Giordano's
4110 E 82nd St 46250
"Visited here with long-time friends who live in the area. This was our first “real†deep dish pizza and it did not disappoint! The crust was not very thick, to our delight, and the ingredients w..."
Saffron Cafe
621 Fort Wayne Avenue 46204
"Oh, my!! What a special treat this was!! The atmosphere was so calm and inviting, the service was personable, dignified, and attentive, and the food was extraordinary! Our party of three each ordered..."
First Watch
3309 E 86th St 46240-2426
"David was the best server! We went on a busy Monday lunch, but he still was very attentive, helpful, and made sure we had the best server! He chatted with us and made sure our food was perfect! Thank..."
Metro Diner
3954 E. 82nd Street 46240
"Came in with a big party Sunday night and none of us had ever eaten here before. A wonderful experience from start to finish. We were seated immediately and promptly greeted by Molly(who was by the wa..."
Long's Bakery
2301 E Southport Rd 46227-5149
"If you want a good inexpensive donut. Go to Long’s. Their original yeast is amazing but you can’t go wrong with trying others. The blueberry cake donut it’s just unbelievably good. The style of..."