Sign in
Hidden gems: restaurants in Tallahassee
Map viewDiscover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Tallahassee. Ratings are based from 452 places in Tallahassee
Kool Beanz Cafe
921 Thomasville Rd Local Eatery with daily menu changes 32303-6219
"Our favorite place to eat in Tallahassee...food choices vary frequently but they keep several of the staples on the menu such as the steak...my personable favorite, along with the lettuce wedge. Food..."
Georgio's Fine Food & Spirits
2971 Apalachee Pkwy 32301-3609
"My husband took me to Georgio's tonight for a quiet celebration of my birthday. It was just our second time there, the first being his job's Christmas party. Like the first time, the food and service..."
The Bada Bean
2500 Apalachee Pkwy 32301-4978
"This is THE place to bring visiting family and friends. I visit or order on my own at least once a month. We love to stop by after Mass on a Sunday morning.I told my daughtera her husband and my ex wh..."
Bird's Aphrodisiac Oyster Shack
325 N Bronough St 32301-1311
"Great dinner, drinks, and atmosphere with live music! I loved the Oysters Rockefeller. Indoor and covered outdoor seating. Small space, but great atmosphere. Be aware that Bird's doesn't always o..."
Jason's Deli
2335 Apalachee Pkwy 32301-4921
"We really enjoyed going there employees are very friendly. Take a great menu. Love the salad bar. I also like places where I can get a half a sandwich and soup soups are always great and the prices ar..."
Blaze Pizza
220 S Magnolia Dr 32301-2980
"I love this place. You are able to customize your own personal sized pizza. It's cooked to order in a matter of minutes in the open pizza oven. I normally prefer a thick crust pizza, but their thin cr..."
Chicken Salad Chick
1410 Market St Ste D3 Suite D3 32312
"I'm not a chicken salad fan at all, but Chicken Salad Chick has some of the BEST, most delicious soups, cookies and sandwiches out there. I've heard their chicken salad is superb. I cannot speak to th..."
Donut Kingdom
685 W Tennessee St 32304-7908
"This place has excellent donuts. Wish they could open a shop in North Florida."
Dog Et Al
1456 S Monroe St 32301-4349
"Been coming here for years every time I'm in Tallahassee. Great prices, great hot dogs, what else could you ask for?"
Brickyard Pizzeria
4819 Kerry Forest Pkwy 32309-2273
"Very friendly staff, wonderful owners and the best pizza in town! We got two pizzas, lasagna, garlic knots and a salad. Everything was amazing and we had tons of leftovers for the next day!I’ll be m..."
Little Athens Gyro
666 W Tennessee St 32304-7989
"Little Athens Gyro is a hidden gem of Tallahassee. Run by a older couple (I think), they are very sweet and make you feel at home.I always get the Euro Supreme w/ Pita Fries, so I can't comment on oth..."
Midtown Pies
1122 Thomasville Rd Ste 4 32303-8702
"I usually get my favorite pizza, gluten-free crust with eggplant, sausage and onion… I was determined to get the pie home on my bicycle but forgot my bungee cord. My new facemask had to stand in to..."
Waffle House
3470 Thomasville Rd 32309-3424
"This was my first visit to a Waffle House and it won't be the last. The cashier was very helpful. The food quality was amazing. Everything was delicious. The manager (Megan) made me feel at home. Terr..."
Fermentation Lounge
415 Saint Francis St 32301-2254
"By far my favorite spot to just hang out in tally. Beers are great and the atmosphere is always dope. They have all kinds of table games and the staff is always real nice to me. 10/10 you will love th..."
Sugar Rush Bar
415 All Saints St Suite 114 32301-2201
"By far the best milkshakes I have ever had. Blink and you'll miss it though. Wonderfully decorated and the staff was very friendly"
Chicken Salad Chick
1496 Apalachee Parkway Unit 14 32301
"The food is simple, the service is very good, and the restaurant is also very clean. We have tried many of the different types of chicken salad. I prefer the spicer brands while my spouse likes the on..."
RikSha Tacos
1955 W Pensacola St 32304-3228
"Their bowls are so great! So much to taste here and all were great each time! Their yogurt sauce with tomatoes is the best. Parking right behind and they are very quick even at busy lunch hours. Decor..."
Real Sarap
435 W Tennessee St 32301-1025
"I had been wanting to try this place forever. The food is excellent and home cooked. Such a great price too for what you get. BBQ pork on a stick and dumplings were my favorite. I went three times in..."
The Crum Box Gastgarden
602 Industrial Dr Railroad Square Art District 32310-4806
"Killer little place! Amazing sausage sandwich! I washed it down with a cold beer and all was perfect. It's a cool little stop for a bite whether your just looking to eat or you're touring the city...."
Jersey Mike's Subs
1355 Market St Ste. A-6 32312-1760
"It was absolutely delicious! I thought subway was good, but man! This place is above and beyond!!! Keep up the good work guys!**just fix the restroom door please**"