Sign in
Hidden gems: restaurants in St. Augustine
Map viewDiscover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in St. Augustine. Ratings are based from 397 places in St. Augustine
Collage Restaurant
60 Hypolita St 32084-3655
"What an experience. This place is simple wonderful. Their 4.8 star google rating is perfectly earned. Our meal was an extravagant achievement of decadent excess. It was simply scintillating! We had..."
O'Steen's Restaurant
205 Anastasia Blvd 32080-4504
"Diner frequented by locals as well as tourists, very loyal patronage. We were visiting St Augustine, and followed a recommendation from a local resident. We were repeatedly told it was "worth the wait..."
The Blue Hen Cafe
117 M L King Ave 32084-4844
"We just were driving through and this stylish restaurant caught my eye. We pulled over and looked it up and their menu sounded amazing. Comfort food with the southern twist. The biscuits are to die fo..."
Barley Republic Public House
48 Spanish St 32084-3636
"We love coming here for either a quick drink, or a hot toddy on a chilly day or a great appetizer. Very good whiskey and beer selection and the staff is very friendly and out going. The inside is ve..."
Preserved Restaurant
102 Bridge St 32084-4310
"We absolutely loved this place. Great service team, melt in your mouth short rib, crispy delicious duck, a creative, well balanced charcuterie board, creamy house made ice creams and a warm gooey peca..."
One Twenty Three Burger House
123 King St 32084-4320
"Great burger joint! Retro look, parking ðŸ‘ðŸ¼. Met at the door by the General Manager who greeted us and opened the door invitingly. We sat at the bar last two seats right in front of the wood fire..."
Georgie's Diner
100 Malaga St 32084-3520
"A Greek Diner with huge, fresh Gyros! Look at the size of that thing! An enchanting retro style and many beautiful flowers and trees on their patio and surroundings. The staff were super friendly and..."
Whetstone Chocolates
139 King St 32084-4325
"The tour was really good. Michael was our tour guide and was very informative. Really enjoyed the artisan chocolates. The taste was a nice surprise. Will definitely be ordering some chocolates. I thin..."
A1A Burrito Works Taco Shop
114 Saint George St 32084-3610
"Every time we come to St. Augustine this is a place we definitely stop and eat at"
St. Augustine Seafood Company
33 Saint George St 32084-3607
"I really loved the vibe. I was in St Augustine on a holiday from NZ just wandering around exploring and I decided to have lunch here. I had a fish taco I think it was called and also some good old fis..."
La Cocina Mexican Restaurant
3290 US Highway 1 S Ste D 32086-6413
"This is the best restaurant in St Augustine, hands down. I have eaten here hundreds of times and the food never gets old. The food is amazing and the staff is always perfect, courteous, and attentive...."
Mojo's
551 Anastasia Blvd 32080-4572
"Very good taco place just minutes from historic St. Augustine. I was pleasantly surprised coming into this place, because I had seen it but never had it before. This is probably the best place to get..."
Caddyshack
World Golf Village
"Late lunch at Murray Bros CaddyShack St Augustine today. Happy to see it super-busy after 2 pm. We enjoyed adult libations and the Crispy Potato Golf Balls with an outstanding horseradish ranch dip (n..."
Trade Winds Lounge
124 Charlotte St 32084-3602
"Tradewinds is a St Augustine institution!! One of the BEST bars for gathering with friends before, during or after a day of exploring the city. There is always a good band playing! The best part about..."
The Cuban Cafe & Bakery
100 Saint George St 32084-6611
"Simple but delicious food, big portion, decent price. Plus, the mojito is really good! Definitely recommend it."
Kings Head British Pub
6460 US Highway 1 N 32095-8263
"We were there at about 3 in the afternoon, just a couple other patrons. Service was excellent. The food fantastic. We had the steak and kidney pie and the cottage pie. It was a cold and rainy afternoo..."
Little Margie's FA Cafe
303 A1A Beach Blvd 32080-7996
"Cute place. We stopped in for breakfast while camping nearby. Exactly what you would expect. I had the seafood skillet and wife had the crab and avocado omelette which was a special. Both were go..."
Odd Birds
33 Charlotte St 32084-3699
"Fantastic drinks! Eclectic spot with a killer Old Fashioned they serve in a sage-infused box. Amazing! Small space with not a lot of elbow room inside but plenty of nice outdoor seating. Great find."
Ichiban Buffet
2185 US Highway 1 S 32086-6070
"This is my favorite Chinese place to eat. Me and my family go almost every week. I love and miss it. It has great sushi, a wide variety of food, and a hibachi. The waiters and host are always kind and..."
Drake's Deli
138 San Marco Ave 32084-3265
"Always consistently fresh and delicious sandwiches. My favorite is the Italian Stallion. Friendly and attentive staff will make you feel right at home. The best option for take out lunch."