Sign in
Hidden gems: restaurants in Middletown
Map viewDiscover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in Middletown. Ratings are based from 88 places in Middletown
Sushi Yama
572 W Main St 19709-1057
"Great place. Quiet atmosphere but welcoming to all. It's not cheap but you get what you pay for. The sushi is excellent. Staff was great. I will be back again."
The Grille at Back Creek
101 Back Creek Dr 19709-8843
"This is the best restaurant in the state of Delaware. Their burgers are the tastiest I ever had. I don't know what kind of beef they're using, but its unbelievable. Their brisket burger is fire."
Los Machados Mexican Restaurant
600 N Broad St Ste 18 19709-1032
"I love this spot! They serve excellent dishes, their menu is nice, The chef in that place is an expert, I love very much trying all their food. The dishes are always of high class, the service towards..."
Stoltzfus BBQ
701 N Broad St Dutch Country Farmer’s Market 19709-1166
"Excellent Place.... Great Food.... Friendly Staff. My Wife and I always love getting the fresh baked Pretzels once you walk in. Then we'll take a walk inside to get their tasty fried chicken...."
Marlenas Medetrranien Deli
10 W Main St Next Door To Sully S Irish Pub In Courtyard 19709-1039
"Very nice local family owned restaurant. Very delicious food with reasonable price. They even gave me a kofta sample + 2 cookies as a Ramadan 🎠gift 💠. I am in love with this place already ...."
Dutch Country Cafe
701 N Broad St Dutch Country Farmers Market 19709-1166
"Excellent Place.... Great Food.... Friendly Staff. My Wife and I always love getting the fresh baked Pretzels once you walk in. Then we'll take a walk inside to get their tasty fried chicken...."
Twisted Frozen Yogurt
482 E Main S 19709
"The yogurt is outstanding and the toppings are unexpectedly numerous. Your palate will thank you with every visit. The only thing you'll ever have to dislike anything about Twisted is the challenge of..."