Sign in
Hidden gems: restaurants in New Milford
Map viewDiscover the city's hidden treasures—remarkable spots that are relatively undiscovered but offer exceptional experiences. Our selection criteria? A rating of 4.5 or higher with fewer than 150 reviews. Explore these lesser-known yet outstanding places that promise a delightful visit in New Milford. Ratings are based from 58 places in New Milford
Ristorante Lucia
51 Bank St 06776-2701
"This is my personal favorite Italian restaurant in the area! We had our company Christmas party here and the food was truly fantastic, cooked beautifully, robust flavors, and an elegant atmosphere...."
DinerLuxe
108 Danbury Rd 06776-3412
"I wish I had gotten pictures, because everything was as appealing to look at as it was to eat! We tried the Roadside Sliders and the Disco Fries... as well as the best slice of Strawberry Cheesecake e..."
Zaragoza Restaurant
31 Bank St 06776-2701
"We like a lot to go out. Yesterday we came to this superb place which we didn’t know before. We had a beautiful evening there with exceptional food and a courteous team and a talented cook. We adde..."
Theo’s Downtown Diner
14 Railroad St Apt 1 06776-2771
"Theo’s is an amazing local diner with delicious breakfast and even better service. Pam always goes out of her way to make sure we have a lovely meal. We have definitely become “regulars†here an..."
The Sweet Spot
60 Railroad St 06776-2718
"We had some delicious ice cream. Cups and a cone. Recommended for your sweet tooth!"
Johana’s Restaurant
47 Main St 06776-2807
"I went here, and it was amazing! I got the waffle with whipped cream and fruit (forgot what it was called) but I enjoyed eating the food here. The place was tiny and cute. One issue is the woman's bat..."
Jo Jo's Deli & Catering
39 Park Lane Rd Ste 5 06776-2923
"The food, service and friendly attitude of Jo Jo's Deli & Catering are at least 5 stars. I went there my first time yesterday and felt like we had known each other for years. It is great to experien..."
Primo's Deli
38 Bridge St 06776-6503
"Absolutely delicious. Grab a Caballito and thank me later."
Green Granary
84 Railroad St 06776-2760
"First time customer and planning on going back soon! Lovely little place and a much needed addition to the New Milford center. Owner is super friendly and accommodating. Being vegan I typically find..."