Whistle Stop Bake Shop

The best cheesecake ever. Even the sugar free cheesecake is amazing. U can't tell it's sugar free

Recommendation from a friend. Wife is a baker and said this was the best NY style cheesecake she's ever had. Definitely off the beaten path, definitely worth the trip

Best overall cheesecake I've had in NY.

Everything here is delicious and is made to perfection. There is so may different options to choose from and they are made really well. The pies and cakes and cannolis are amazing and I would recommend going here if you are looking to get something sweet or something for a party.

Best cheesecake ever! Also friendly and pleasant staff. However, I would bring cash! They charge a 3.5% convenience fee for any credit card transactions.

Met with Lisa, the baker for my sister's wedding. She was professional & friendly. Amswered all our questions! Definitely recommend this bakery....now to solve our filling conundrum!!! Decisions, decisions, decisions!!!😳

If you want a cheese cake from one of the cleanest bakeries east of nyc . Whistle stop is the place to go , been getting cakes from this place for years . If you need your holiday desserts go early cause this place is well known

How many times zipping down Lawson Blvd. heading to the beach I passed Whistle Stop but kept going. Well, no more! I entered this shop and could not believe how beautiful each decadent offering was tempting me. Now you won't have lots of time to ponder your selection as a line quickly forms behind you. The variety of cheesecakes is stellar and their other cakes, like a chocolate one I purchased, was an indulgence I savored to the very last piece. They also offer delicious butter cookies, crumb cakes and pies that look just like Martha Stewart must be working overtime in the back. So next time you are asked to bring dessert, bring Whistle Stop, your parents, your children, and your friends will all thank you!

Great deserts and Employees are friendly

The best cheesecake on Long Island.

The best cheesecake & desserts ever!!!!

Great place for buying cheesecakes. My most favorite cake of theirs is the one with four fruit toppings (cherry, pineapple, blueberries and strawberries).Prices are reasonable. Parking is small. Could use a larger parking lot because of how well their business is.Maybe consider an extra hour or two per day or extended hours on Friday and Saturday.

The best cheesecake ever. & much more love the fruit pies, carrot cake, extra large macaroon s.

AMAZING BAKERY!!! THEY HAVE CHEESECAKES EVER !! THEY ARE A MUST STOP WHENEVER I AM ON LONG ISLAND VISITING MY FAMILY .

Hello world, if you ever visit long Island and don't try this bakery, that's just a tragedy... I'm considered a food critic in my house,and I disprefer biased information or reviews. This is not the first time I've been to this bakery, and I'm trying to withhold some of my excitement but yes I would absolutely recommend this bakery to try atleast once if you're ever land in Long Island. One word that comes to mind is the bakery is rich, and very full.Warning : this is not your regular bakery stuff! You are entering this world of flavors at your 9wn risk.Highly recommend : I'm assuming everything but what I always get are the raspberry and apricot bars and the canolisThis visit we tried the above and :Lemon poppy + apple crust muffins,Plane cream cheese cup cake and a chocolate peanut butter cupcake.Thank you for reading and enjoy your visit world!