Sign in
Whistle Stop Bake Shop
About
- 4.7 ( 46 reviews)
- $$, $$$
| Day of the Week | Opening Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday | 9:00 - 18:00 |
| Tuesday | 9:00 - 18:00 |
| Wednesday | 9:00 - 18:00 |
| Thursday | 9:00 - 18:00 |
| Friday | 9:00 - 18:00 |
| Saturday | 9:00 - 18:00 |
| Sunday | 9:00 - 18:00 |
Cuisines
- 🍔 American
Dining Options
- ♿ Wheelchair Accessible
- 🥡 Takeout
Recommended Reviews
5
4
3
2
1
4.7
😀
2018-11-09
on google
Margaret Andriano
The best cheesecake ever. Even the sugar free cheesecake is amazing. U can't tell it's sugar free
😍
2018-11-06
on google
nick wargo
Recommendation from a friend. Wife is a baker and said this was the best NY style cheesecake she's ever had. Definitely off the beaten path, definitely worth the trip
😍
2018-11-04
on google
Noel Almodovar Jr
Best overall cheesecake I've had in NY.
Questions & Answers
I didn't do shipping when I went there. It was in store pick up.
They are not kosher
Call them to check. They used to ship before but when the Hurricane hit their machine was destroyed and as far as I know they didn't get a new one.
They don't make strawberry cheesecake but they put strawberries on top
????
No they're not
Give them a call
I'm not sure call them
I believe they do
At least a week
Nearest places
View all
Blvd Eats
- 4.9 (24)
- $$
- 745 ft from the location
Schnitz and Gigglez
- 3 (0)
- $$
- 1135 ft from the location
Dunkin'
- 3.9 (50)
- $$
- 2566 ft from the location
7-Eleven
- 3 (7)
- $$
- 2844 ft from the location
Subway
- 4.7 (12)
- $$
- 2877 ft from the location
Lo's Green Garden
- 4.1 (10)
- $$
- 2904 ft from the location
Ralph's Italian Ices-Oceanside
- 4.7 (17)
- $$
- 2940 ft from the location
A & S Fine Foods Incorporated
- 4.5 (0)
- $$
- 2953 ft from the location
Noble Kitchen and Cocktails
- 4.5 (0)
- $$
- 2956 ft from the location
Last updated information: 2024-05-26