Rustique Pizzeria

Excellent food and a great vibe! Their pizza is worth a drive all the way from Appleton! There isn't a single WI pizza restaurant south of Rustique who can match their menu, quaint atmosphere, and friendly waitstaff.

Have been here twice and seems like no matter the time it's always busy, but well worth the wait! Wife and I are in love with the pesto frys and we also tried there pizza that was on the specials board which was the thai pie.

Very crammed with people and tables, and conversation was loud. Hard to talk to the people at our own table. The pizza was delicious, and while special beyond typical pizza, felt over-priced. The building is historic and interesting. Server was friendly but barely saw her.

Amazing pizza! Decided to do curb side pick up during quarantine and it was a 10/10 choice. The phone lines to place an order were busy so they accommodated with Facebook Messenger ordering which was awesome. Went and picked up the order and food was still warm and delicious by time I got it home. The whole family was extremely satisfied with full belly’s. This place is a must!

Have been there many times and food and service has always been great. Last time we were there an order was forgotten/misplaced, the staff/management went above and beyond to fix the issue and make it up to us. Stuff happens, I was impressed with how they took care of it, so we still had a great night!

Pretty good. Great selection. They didn’t have ripe enough plantains for the appetizer which was a bummer, but the rest was spot on.

In a word - awesome! A must visit location for out-of-towners and local residents alike who seek a great atmosphere, friendly and attentive staff, tasty brick oven pizza, and so much more! Definitely order the amazing garlic pesto fries! The perch is very tasty as well! Go frequently knowing you will always leave full and happy! Thanks Rustique - you ROCK and we will be back often!

Food for thought.. when one owns a business, let's say a restaurant, probably shouldn't tell a party of 14 with a reservation you have already backed up 30 minutes (and the party was accommodating to that request-not always easy with a large group) who is questioning what is going on... you don't need to be here! Last I checked customers are exactly where your revenue comes from... P.S. my sister overheard the server/employee state no way we were getting sat on time because they weren't gonna rush the "big tippers" sitting at the table.. after I was told when I made reservation big table had a strict 1.5 hr time limit... and the owner wanted my daughter on crutches to go back out in snowstorm to wait in car for table... this was after I stated at minimum we needed a chair for her. Unf****** believable!!

Great service and good prices. The pesto fries are a wonderful way to start.

This place is so cool being a old church and the food is amazing and good.

The food is amazing here, everything has great flavours and it has great variety to choose from. I dislike this place only because of the seating area - it's so loud and packed that it's tough to enjoy conversation. It does have a great view of the brick ovens and then pizza spinning chefs - but id much rather a place where I could here conversation at a normal volume

Food was fantastic. The menu is easy to understand. Over a great experience. Negatives were that there is no list of drinks other than adult beverages. Our waiter only showed up 4 times. Still, the food was great.

We were told 30 minute wait time. It was an hour. Great atmosphere, bar and wait staff. Food good. Little longer on the oven for the pizza.

Wow! The pizza here is amazing, sitting outside on the patio was great. Do not let the full parking lot fool you, there was plenty of seating available. There is a great beer and mixed drinks menu and their gelato was delicious! You can also get half and half pizzas which was perfect for my husband and I who did not need a full pizza for each of us, but can never agree on toppings!

I'll separate this into two categories: 1. Food; 2. Atmosphere.First, the food is excellent. Wood fired pizzas, great ingredient combos. Atmosphere: The place is small, with smallish tables. It's loud as there is a lot of wood and a relatively small space. We were seated at a small table with 5 adults and it was really tight.So if you're looking for a quiet place to relax and have a pizza, this isn't it. Get the pizza to go if you need to unwind.