Rustique Pizzeria

Excellent food and a great vibe! Their pizza is worth a drive all the way from Appleton! There isn't a single WI pizza restaurant south of Rustique who can match their menu, quaint atmosphere, and friendly waitstaff.

Have been here twice and seems like no matter the time it's always busy, but well worth the wait! Wife and I are in love with the pesto frys and we also tried there pizza that was on the specials board which was the thai pie.

Very crammed with people and tables, and conversation was loud. Hard to talk to the people at our own table. The pizza was delicious, and while special beyond typical pizza, felt over-priced. The building is historic and interesting. Server was friendly but barely saw her.