Sign in
The Best restaurants in Bay Shore
Map viewCaptain Bill's
122 Ocean Ave 11706-8719
"I sat at the bar, service was fast and friendly. Seems like a lot of regulars go there. Lots of conversation. Portions are large. Loved that Captain Bill's is a supporter of local community organizat..."
Nicky's On the Bay
South Clinton Ave Bay Shore Marina 11706
"Great place to eat! Loved the oysters and seared tuna steak. The restaurant itself is airy and just a pleasure - family friendly, kid friendly. Our server Jessica was amazing and even ran out after me..."
Fat Fish Bar & Bistro
28 Cottage Ave 11706-8659
"The lamb shank and crawfish soup were excellent. Great restaurant!"
Tula Kitchen
41 E Main St 11706-8303
"This place is obviously one of the best place in the area. Anytime I come there I am profoundly glad. They manage their very high standard service and the highest level of dishes they serve. You wil..."
Peter Pan Diner
999 Sunrise Hwy 11706-5909
"Picked up a pre-ordered lunch today- couldn't have been easier- it was ready and waiting. Food was great- everything was there- fork/knife, napkins, dressing, pita bread (warm!). I'll be ordering ag..."
Tullulah's
12 4th Ave 11706-7909
"I've been to this establishment a couple of times now and I look forward to returning. We sampled the autumn menu on one occasion and were absolutely delighted, every bite was exceptional and I loved..."
Swept Away
25 Bayview Ave 11706-8743
"Casual and delicious! Fair pricing, friendly service and a warm place on a rainy night for a family dinner at the holidays! The largest pork chop I’ve ever seen, a seafood platter that was delicio..."
Salt & Barrel
61 W Main St 11706-8370
"Great place for rest and wellness! I feel very well after spending time in a salt room, it becomes easier to breathe, somewhere my allergic rhinitis disappears. Thank you for being there !!!)"
Chowder Bar
123 Maple Ave 11706-8735
"This place is awesome! Very quaint and cozy little place with friendly service and delicious food. The fish sandwich was definitely the best I've ever had, with yummy home made tartar sauce. Definitel..."
Verde kitchen & cocktails
70 E Main St 11706-8301
"An experience that I will repeat. Visited on a Saturday afternoon. Sat at the greenhouse area. Our waitress Eleanor was simply amazing. She was able to recommend drinks and foods based on our likes/di..."
Pico Tequila Grill
19 W Main St 11706-8307
"Went here for taco Tuesday deal and the tacos were legit crazy good. Might make it a tradition to just go there Tuesdays when I'm hungry with the boys. Place has a nice selection of beer as well and t..."
Nicky's Clam Bar
99 Maple Ave 11706-8735
"If your looking for some delicious seafood give this place a try. I had the fried oysters and whole belly clams, both were very flavorful and cooked perfectly. They also have a nice beer selection."
Peninsula Chinese and Japanese
55 W Main St 11706-8307
"The food was fantastic. We went there with my niece and nephew for dinner. It's over 20 miles from my house. But we will go back. The service was great. The place was very clean and and friendly. If y..."
Whalers
124 Maple Ave 11706-8737
"I had the pleasure of taking my wife to an early Valentine's day brunch and we did it today. We were warmly greeted by the hostess and seated quickly once our confirmation of our reservation was done..."