Wise Guys Pizza

I use to love wise guys cause every time I would pick up my pizza they would open it up and be like “look good” and it looked so good and tasted good but once I stared getting delivery and not picking it up, the pizza would come basically burnt... the first time it happen I was like w.e but then it kept on happening so now I won’t order from them anymore... I feel like when you do delivery they figure “oh well” when the pizza comes out bad but who knows... I will say the Cannolis are super good and pizza is good if picking up

I come here every time I'm in Buffalo and I am never disappointed. I love this place so much and would highly recommend this place to anyone who wants some real, authentic buffalo pizza. Plus everyone is so friendly.

The staff was helpful and accommodating, even dealt with my weird order preferences with a smile and a chuckle. The food is large in proportion, so if you are on a diet.... well you shouldn't be here in the first place haha. Has an ambience that feels similar to a pizza shop in an 80's movie complete with upbeat, boppy music. All in all,a solid place to eat.

My boyfriend and me are loyal Wise Guys fans and have been for many years. However, recently there has been a downgrade in the food quality. We've noticed that the pizza has become smaller yet more expensive. The large now looks like a medium and it used to be big, plus the price has gotten more expensive. We've noticed the sauce recipe has changed and also the bleu cheese recipe changed which used to be our favorite. We just ordered and they forgot to deliver a 2 liter that we payed for and they didn't credit me or bring one back to our house. It's a shame. Really used to love this place, but I think we'll take our business elsewhere.

Great Food With Friendly Service! This place never disappoints. It's clean, the staff are friendly, and the portions are great! You can get breakfast any time of day which is a plus. Make sure you check out their Sunday brunch buffet. You can get french toast, bacon, eggs, potatoes, sausage, chicken wings, beef, chicken, and desserts. One of my favorite places to eat in Allentown.

Ordered a chicken finger sub over the phone today. The guy taking the order was short with me and very impersonal, bordering rude. When I opened my sub, it was completely wrong. Asked for hot fingers and blue cheese, with BBQ sauce on side. They gave me plain fingers, ketchup on side, no blue cheese, and American cheese on the sub (I asked for no other cheese, just blue). Food looks good, but I'm not eating a plain chicken finger sub with ketchup. I'm not a monster.

They show up when they say they will. Prices are fair. The wings are always crunchy there never squishy. Since moving to buffalo from Rochester it's been a struggle to find a decent Pizza and wing place. There's less than 5 places in the entire city of Buffalo that I would recommend to anyone and this place is one of them!

Just discovered their *awesome* pizza about 2 months ago.So here’s a new one, who’d have thought that the way a sub is wrapped is important, right? Yet, we discovered, it is!Ordered subs tonight and the way Wiseguys wrapped them was awesome!They didn’t fall apart when opened, and that is a beautiful (and delicious!) thing..!

We stopped and got 4 large pizzas. They did an OUTSTANDING job. Very professional and the pizzas were top of the line. We shall return!

I love wise guys! Their sauce is sweet and delicious. Everything tastes fresh. The theme of the pizzeria is super dope!

Staff here is amazing. Steven took my order and everything was perfect. Wounderful South Buffalo pizza place for sure. Never disappointed. Thank you Wise Guys Pizza

Have GREAT GLUTEN FREE CRUST love it. A little on the pricier side. those who are on a gluten free diet understand good gluten free crust is hard to come by. Me and my boyfriend order from them all the time. They’re right around the corner from me and always super friendly!

JAY'S WISE GUYS PIZZA has officially taken over south Buffalo! Stuffed crust pizza! Yes stuffed crust! The customer here is outstanding! As a business owner I know how important customer service is. I will now for ever support the #MAFIA chicken wing dip pizza , pepperoni pizza with honey sesame stuff crust & a 15 piece of mango habanero/ loganberry chicken fingers!

fish fry: though i generally like wise guys food and prices, the fish fry portion is half of what it used to be for $17.00 . wiechec's lounge on clinton street will give you more than double the portion for $15 and is the top fishfry restaurant in buffalo.

The wings? Outstanding. My mother, a Buffalonian since her birth in 1953 says “quite honestly, these are the best wings I’ve ever had!” And we agree. Super easy online ordering, and kind & courteous staff.