Treasure Island Supper Club

True to its name, this is truly a Dayton treasure! Whether we order prime rib or seafood, the entrees are always sizzling hot and mouthwatering! Not only that, the salads are crisp and delicious, and the sides, such as the Lyonnais potatoes, are fab. If you haven't dined here, treat yourself!

We love Treasure Island. Have been going there for over 25 years. Last night was the worst in 25 years. I had the Pork Tenderloin Sandwich and it was huge and delicious. My husband however had a cup of Chili which was good but he also had the "Seafood Platter" which consisted of one very small piece of cod, two shrimp, one small stuffed crab, two small frog legs, two small scallops and side of decent broccoli. The seafood was all undercooked and tasted "boxed". For $18.95 an Admirals Feast at Red Lobster is a MUCH better meal. The service and ambiance was good as usual. We will be back but cautious about what we order and hopeful of a better experience.

OMG! That is all I can say. I went there the other night for the first time. WHAT A GEM. I had the best ribeye since I can remember. So flavorful!! Our waitress was so attentive. She shared stories of the restaurant from long ago. She has been there 30 years and still loves her job, as is evident by the service she provided. We also had a busser who was just so accommodating. We gave him a $10 tip just to show our appreciation. I can honestly say, this is my new "go to" restaurant. Keep doing what you're doing. I'm spreading the word.