Tony's Pizza New York Style

Displaced family from the hurricane florence. Staying at hotel which is around the corner from the restaurant. Took almost an hour for delivery (was told 35min). Cheese sticks had no flavor. Menu shows toppings, but not the fact that mayo is globbed on their sandwiches. Asked for extra oil and vinegar for my wife's sub, and they might as well pulled it from the Sahara desert. Not happy. Because we headed back to NC in the morning, no time for them to fix this. Just going to share my son's nuggets. Those were decent. As stated, we on the road. I also stated that there was no time for you all to fix this. No worries, just a bad orderAndy

Being from the home of the best pizza in the country (NY/CT) this is the best I have had in my 3 years here in Columbia. Nice thin crust. Highly recommend.

Good food quality good customer service.

Bland bland bland. Hot wings had no zip, and I’m not a fan of blazing sauces. Pizza crust was limp and doughy. Red sauce was uninspired. Only reason I gave 2 stars was it wasn’t greasy, was delivered hot and within the time frame promised. Not even close to a New York pizza. Disappointed.

Horrible wings and pizza. It is definitely not any New York style pizza I have ever had. It is an odd and awkward place. Stay away from this place. I had stomach pains all night after eating a meat lovers pizza and the Parmesan wing.

Flavor was great. In my opinion the crust was too thin.

I've never actually been able to eat here. But, we have tried to stop in to eat 3 different times (all within an hour and a half after the posted opening time), and Tony's has been closed, all lights off, no one inside even prepping to open. To me, that doesn't seem like the type of company really wanting to build a good clientele.

Amazing food, amazing customer service. What more could one want?

this ain’t it ... you ain’t slick with them wavy fries from Walmart . McDonald’s is better tbh

We ordered 2 pizzas from here one mushroom. One bacon pizza. Mushroom was good i really loved the crust better then most the non francise resturants around here. The bacon taste pretty bad. The sauce and cheese was really good. I feel like advice to the owner shouldimprove his quality of ingridents. But if you are wanting a non francise resturant i would recommand here.

Pizza and calzone taste like homemade no artificial flavors and great customer serves.

The food and service is fantastic! The new management is making this the best pizza in Columbia, try them, you won't be disappointed!

Pizza was not New York style. All you can taste was alot of garlic. A little pricey just for a slice. I would not go back there.

Great pizza and breadsticks. Allowed us to move toppings from one pizza to another, to get the best deal. Friendly staff, nice outside eating area.

Always amazing pizza. Great prices. Very friendly and fast staff. Small but not cramped. They are serving a freshly made personal pizza instead of slices for 2.99$ , that shows how much they care about the quality of their food , i find the price reasonable