The Wurlitzer Pizza Co., Inc.

Name: The Wurlitzer Pizza Co., Inc.
Address: 1401 Nash Road 14120, North Tonawanda, New York
Telephone: 17166944799

Menu last updated: 2024-01-29

Appetizers

Potato Munchers

7.55

Pizza Logs

Pizza sauce.

Sweet Potato Fries

5.85
0.35

Jalapeno Poppers

With blue cheese.

Curly-Q Fries

4.65
6.2
0.35

Mozzarella Sticks

With pizza sauce.

Loaded Fries

Cheese & bacon.

6.55
9.1
0.35

Potato Skins

11.2

Loaded Tater Tots

Cheese & bacon.

6.55
9.1

Deep Fried Mushrooms

Cheese Fries

5.75
7.35
0.35

Deep Fried Cauliflower

Onion Rings

5
6.75

Deep Fried Banana Peppers

With sauce.

French Fries

4.2
6.2
0.35
0.85

Potato Salad

Cajun Fries

4.65
6.15
0.35

Macaroni Salad

Hot Fries

4.65
6.15
0.35

Pretzel Sticks

10.15

Greek Fries

Greek dressing, feta cheese.

6.55
9.1
0.35

Nachos with Cheese

6.75

Chicken Quesadillas

11.55

Nachos with Beef & Cheese

Steak Quesadillas

11.55

Loaded Nachos

Beef, cheese, salsa, sour cream, black olives, jalapenos, lettuce.

8.25
1

Garlic Bread Strips with Mozzarella

With sauce on side.

15.3
16.95

Five Cheese Stuffed Banana Peppers

11.4

Garlic Bread with Melted Mozzarella

Fried Dough with Powdered Sugar & Cinnamon

9.25
1.7
1.7

Garlic Bread with Melted Mozzarella & Tomatoes

Black Raspberry Sauce

Spinach Bread with Garlic & Melted Mozzarella

Chocolate Sauce

Hot Banana Pepper Bread (Blended Hot Cheeses)

9.25
1.65

Deep Fried Oreos

Deep-fried Oreos choice of chocolate or raspberry dipping sauce.

Vegan Loaded Cheese & Bacon Tots

8.65

Vegan Hot Pepper Bread

10.7

Vegan Tots

6.25

Vegan Deep Fried Oreos

Served with choice of chocolate or raspberry dipping sauce.

5.45

Vegan Sweet Potato Fries

5.4
0.65

Vegan Pretzel Sticks

10.15

Vegan French Fries

4.2
6.2
0.65

Vegan Loaded Nachos

Chips, lettuce, salsa, beyond beef, black olives, jalapenos, cheese.

9.65

Vegan Cajun Fries

4.65
6.15
0.65

Vegan Garlic Bread with Cheese

Vegan Hot Fries

4.15
5.9
1.5
0.65

Vegan Garlic Bread with Spinach

Vegan Curly Q Fries

4.65
6.2
0.65

Vegan Garlic Bread with Tomato

Vegan Quesadillas

'Chicken' or veggie.

13.15

Vegan Garlic Bread Strips

With vegan mozzarella & vegan sauce on the side.

16.95

Vegan Fried Dough

Vegan Stuffed Banana Peppers

Fresh peppers stuffed with homemade filling, served with a roll.

13.4

Beverages

Soda

Choose Soda: Select only one - Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Cherry Coke

3.24
4.17

Milkshake

Choose Flavor: Select only one - Vanilla, Chocolate, Peanut Butter.

5.79
7.36

Salads

Side Salad

Antipasto Salad

12.5
17.55
25.15
46.3

Taco Salad

With beef or chicken.

15.35

Pecan & Cranberry Salad

12.5
17.55
25.3
46.4

Chef Salad

10.5
14.9
22.55
40.95

Pecan & Cranberry Salad with Chicken

13.95
19.55
28.35
51.5

Chef Salad with Chicken

12.2
17.35
28.05
50.9

Pecan & Cranberry Salad with Steak

13.95
19.55
28.35
51.5

Chef Salad with Chicken

12.2
17.35
28.05
50.9

Pecan & Cranberry Salad with Steak

13.95
19.55
28.35
51.5

Chef Salad with Steak

12.2
17.35
28.05
50.9

Greek Salad

10.6
15.15
22.5
40.45

Chef Salad with Bacon

12.2
17.35
28.05
50.9

Greek Salad with Chicken

12.5
17.95
26.9
49

Chef Salad with Fingers

12.2
17.35
28.05
50.9

Caesar Salad

10.6
15.15
22.5
40.9

Julienne Salad

12.5
16.8
24.6
44.9

Caesar Salad with Chicken

12.5
17.95
26.9
49.05

Tuna Chef Salad

12.5
17.55
25.4
47.7

Pizza

Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

17.95
20.35
21.35
35.95

Cheese & 1 Topping Pizza

19.75
22.75
23.35
41.65

Pulled Pork Pizza

Oil base, pulled pork, cheddar & BBQ sauce.

25.15
29.35
30.45
57.95

Pickle Pie

Pickles, Swiss American, oil, garlic, mozzarella, dill.

21.6
24.75
25.65
49.05

Stuffed Banana Pepper Pizza

Blended spicy cheese base, banana peppers, sausage, bread crumbs and mozzarella.

23.65
27.1
28.2
53.35

Meat Lovers Pizza

Red sauce base, topped with pepperoni, ham, sausage, bacon and mozzarella cheese.

25.15
29.35
30.45
57.95

Steak & Cheese Pizza

Mozzarella, Swiss American, Romano, mushrooms, onions, hot or sweet peppers, topped with tender steak, olive oil, garlic.

25.15
29.35
30.45
57.95

Deluxe Veggie Pizza

Mozzarella & cheddar cheese topped with mushrooms, green & black olives, hot & sweet peppers & onions plus broccoli, spinach, tomatoes.

23.75
27.6
28.4
54.4

Godfather Pizza

Mozzarella, whole tomatoes in sauce, olive oil, garlic, crisp onions, Romano & hot or sweet peppers with your choice of pepperoni, sausage, anchovies or hamburger.

21.65
26.5
27.4
53.25

Spicy Taco Pizza

Spicy seasoned ground beef, sliced tomatoes, light crisp onions, hot or sweet peppers with cheddar & mozzarella topped with black olives, sauce or salsa base.

22.95
26.3
27.4
54.05

The Nashville (Spicy) Pizza

Mozzarella, chicken fingers, pickles, olive oil, cole slaw, Nashville sauce.

21.65
26.5
27.4
53.25

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Choice of chicken fingers or grilled chicken. Ranch dressing base, topped with tomatoes, onions, sweet peppers, mozzarella cheese and bacon.

22.95
23.4
26.3
54.04

White Pizza

Heavy Romano cheese with olive oil, garlic, Fontinella, mozzarella, whole tomatoes, oregano, onions, hot & sweet peppers. (Anchovies if desired).

20.6
23.35
24.45
47.05

Old World Sauce Pie

Heavy pizza sauce with Romano cheese, onions & choice of pepperoni or sausage.

18.45
21.45
22.5
42.05

Buffalo Style Pizza

BBQ, hot, medium, or mild chicken fingers, blue cheese, mozzarella.

23.1
26.3
27.4
54.75

Stinger Pie

Blue cheese dressing, steak, chicken finger, hot peppers, onions, mozzarella & cheddar cheese.

27.4
29.95
31.1
60.7

Greek Pizza

Greek dressing, green peppers, onions, steak or chicken, feta cheese, light mozzarella & Greek olives.

22.75
26.5
27.4
53.25

Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

Mayo, mustard, ketchup, hamburger, pickles, cheddar & mozzarella cheese, onion and bacon.

25.15
29.35
30.45
57.95

Popeye Pizza

Spinach, onion, sausage on an oil garlic base covered with ricotta and mozzarella cheese.

21.1
24.05
25.15
49.05

Sausage & Steak Pizza

Olive oil, garlic, red sauce, sausage and steak, light onion, sweet peppers, mozzarella and Romano cheese.

25.15
29.35
30.85
57.95

Mighty Wurlitzer Pizza

Mozzarella, mushrooms, green & black olives, hot & sweet peppers, onions, Margherita pepperoni & Italian sausage, anchovies if desired.

24.1
27.4
28.5
54.25

Mediterranean Pizza

Oil garlic base, roasted Brussel sprouts, spinach, olives, feta, red onion, roasted red peppers, tomato & mozzarella.

22.75
26.5
27.35
53.25

Hawaiian Pizza

Red sauce base, topped with pineapple, ham and mozzarella cheese.

21.1
24.05
25.15
49.05

Wurly Mack Pizza

Burger, pickle, diced onion, house-made thousand island, cheddar cheese, sesame crust topped with shredded lettuce.

23
26.3
27.4
51.9

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Cheese & 1 Topping Pizza

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Pickle Pie

Pickles, Swiss American, oil, garlic, mozzarella, dill.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Pulled Pork Pizza

Oil base pulled pork, cheddar & BBQ sauce.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Meat Lovers Pizza

Red sauce base, topped with pepperoni, ham, sausage, bacon and mozzarella cheese.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Stuffed Banana Pepper Pizza

Blended spicy cheese base, banana peppers, sausage, bread crumbs and mozzarella.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Deluxe Veggie Pizza

Mozzarella & cheddar cheese topped with mushrooms, green & black olives, hot & sweet peppers & onions plus broccoli, spinach, tomatoes.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Steak & Cheese Pizza

Mozzarella, Swiss American, Romano, mushrooms, onions, hot or sweet peppers, topped with tender steak, olive oil, garlic.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Spicy Taco Pizza

Spicy seasoned ground beef, sliced tomatoes, light crisp onions, hot or sweet peppers with cheddar & mozzarella topped with black olives, sauce or salsa base.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Godfather Pizza

Mozzarella, whole tomatoes in sauce, olive oil, garlic, crisp onions, Romano & hot or sweet peppers with your choice of pepperoni, sausage, anchovies or hamburger.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Choice of chicken fingers or grilled chicken. Ranch dressing base, topped with tomatoes, onions, sweet peppers, mozzarella cheese and bacon.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan the Nashville (Spicy) Pizza

Mozzarella, chicken fingers, pickles, olive oil, cole slaw, Nashville sauce.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Old World Sauce Pie

Heavy pizza sauce with Romano cheese, onions & choice of pepperoni or sausage.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan White Pizza

Heavy Romano cheese with olive oil, garlic, Fontinella, mozzarella, whole tomatoes, oregano, onions, hot & sweet peppers. (Anchovies if desired).

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Stinger Pie

Blue cheese dressing, steak, chicken finger, hot peppers, onions, mozzarella & cheddar cheese.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Buffalo Style Pizza

BBQ, hot, medium, or mild chicken fingers, blue cheese, mozzarella.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

Mayo, mustard, ketchup, hamburger, pickles, cheddar & mozzarella cheese, onion and bacon.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Greek Pizza

Greek dressing, green peppers, onions, steak or chicken, feta cheese, light mozzarella & Greek olives.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Sausage & Steak Pizza

Olive oil, garlic, red sauce, sausage and steak, light onion, sweet peppers, mozzarella and Romano cheese.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Popeye Pizza

Spinach, onion, sausage on an oil garlic base covered with ricotta and mozzarella cheese.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Mediterranean Pizza

Oil garlic base, roasted Brussel sprouts, spinach, olives, feta, red onion, roasted red peppers, tomato & mozzarella.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Mighty Wurlitzer Pizza

Mozzarella, mushrooms, green & black olives, hot & sweet peppers, onions, Margherita pepperoni & Italian sausage, anchovies if desired.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Wurly Mack Pizza

Burger, pickle, diced onion, house-made thousand island, cheddar cheese, sesame crust topped with shredded lettuce.

10.15

Sicilian Style Deep Pan Hawaiian Pizza

Red sauce base, topped with pineapple, ham and mozzarella cheese.

10.15

Vegan Cheese Pizza

19.95

Vegan Wurly Mack Pizza

Beyond Burger, pickle, diced onion, house-made thousand island, vegan cheddar cheese, sesame crust topped with shredded lettuce.

29.45

Vegan Deluxe Veggie Pizza

Vegan mozzarella, vegan cheddar, mushrooms, onions, hot & sweet peppers, green & black olives, spinach, broccoli, and tomatoes.

28.9

Vegan the Nashville (Spicy) Pizza

27.5

Vegan White Pizza

Olive oil and garlic base topped with sliced tomatoes, oregano, onions, hot & sweet peppers, and vegan mozzarella.

23.6

Vegan Stuffed Banana Pepper Pizza

Oil garlic base, homemade pepper dip, fresh banana peppers, beyond sausage, vegan mozzarella.

29.45

Vegan Dill Pickle Pizza

Olive oil and garlic base topped with dill pickles, vegan mozzarella, oregano, and dill.

23.4

Vegan Taco Pizza

Salsa or sauce base topped with spicy seasoned vegan "ground beef", sliced tomatoes, onions, hot OR sweet peppers, black olives, vegan mozzarella, and vegan cheddar.

29.45

Vegan Cheeseburger Pizza

Vegan mayo, mustard, ketchup, beyond burger, pickles, onion, vegan mozzarella, and vegan cheddar.

29.7

Vegan Buffalo Chicken Pizza

House-made vegan blue cheese base topped with house-made buffalo tofu "chicken" (hot, med, or mild), and vegan mozzarella.

29.45

Vegan Supreme Pizza

Vegan red sauce base vegan mozzarella, green pepper, red onion, mushroom, beyond sausage.

29.6

Vegan Chicken Ranch Pizza

Vegan ranch base topped with house-made tofu "chicken", tomatoes, onions, sweet peppers, and vegan mozzarella.

24.55

Vegan Mediterranean Pizza

Oil garlic base, roasted Brussel sprouts, spinach, olives, feta, red onion, roasted red peppers, tomato & vegan mozzarella.

29.75

Vegan Sicilian Style Deep Pan Cheese & 1 Topping Pizza

10.95

Vegan Specialty Sicilian Style Deep Pan Pizza

12.45

Cheese Pizza Slice

3.95

Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza Slice

3.95

Subs

Cheese Sub

8.62
9.8

Tuna White Albacore Sub

9.35
11.8

Ham Sub

9.35
11.8

Turkey-Gourmet Oven Roasted Sub

9.35
11.8

Cappicola Sub

9.35
11.8

Roast Beef Sub

9.35
11.8

Salami Sub

9.35
11.8

Ham & Turkey Sub

9.35
11.8

Assorted Sub

Cappicola, ham, salami.

9.35
11.8

Turkey Club Sub

10.45
12.45

Steak & Cheese Sub

13.2
15.4

Pizza Sub

9
10.15

Sausage & Cheese Sub

10.85
12.2

Royal Sub

11.85
13.7

Chicken Finger Sub

11.75
13.5

BLT Sub

8.55
10.75

Bacon Cheeseburger Sub

13.1
15.3

Veggie Sub

8.55
10.75

Cheeseburger Sub

12.75
15

Fish Sub

10.35
12.05

Grilled Chicken Breast Sub

10.65
12.65

Steak Souvlaki Sub

Tomato, green peppers, lettuce, onion & feta.

12.85
15.7

Chicken In the Grass Sub

On garlic roll.

12.85
15.7

Chicken Souvlaki

Tomato, green peppers, lettuce, onion & feta.

12.85
15.7

Steak & Finger (Stinger) Sub

13.1
17.2

Steak Hoagie

Fried peppers & onions.

12.85
15.7

Chicken Parmigiana Sub

10.35
12.65

Sausage Hoagie

Fried peppers & onions.

12.85
15.7

Meatball Sub

11.6
13.25

Chicken Hoagie

Fried peppers & onions.

12.85
15.7

Eggplant Parmigiana Sub

10.35
12.05

Steak in the Grass Sub

On garlic roll.

12.85
15.7

Vegan Cheese Sub

10.95

Vegan BLT Sub

Vegan bacon, lettuce, tomato and vegan mayo.

10.95

Vegan Chicken Fingers Sub

Hot, medium, mild.

12.75

Vegan Taco

Hot, med, or mild spicy seasoned vegan "ground beef" or "chicken" with lettuce, tomato, and vegan cheddar.

13.6

Vegan Cheeseburger Sub

15.2

Vegan Sausage Hoagie

Vegan sausage with sautéed peppers & onions and vegan mozzarella.

14.7

Vegan Pizza Sub

10.95

Vegan Chicken Parm Sub

Vegan sauce, "chicken", vegan mozzarella.

12.4

Vegan Veggie Sub

10.95

Wings and Fingers

Buffalo Style Chicken Wings

Mild, medium, hot, or suicidal. Charbroiled.

13.3
22.65
33.75
50.9

Buffalo Style Boneless Wings

Mild, medium, hot, or suicidal. Charbroiled.

13.3
22.65
33.75
50.9

Specialty Wings

15.3
24.65
35.75
52.9

Vegan Wings

Served with celery.

10.95
1.5
1.5

Chicken Fingers

Includes French fries, fries, celery, blue cheese & garlic bread.

14.95
21.95
29.75
37.15

Sandwiches

Pulled Pork Sandwich

Bacon Cheeseburger

9.65

Roast Beef Sandwich

Bacon Blue Burger

10.55

Hot Pot Roast Sandwich

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

8.25

Hot Dog

Crispy Chicken Sandwich

9.05

Wurlitzer Burger

10.4

Fish Sandwich

Wurlitzer Burger with Cheese

10.75

Tuna Sandwich

Veggie Burger

8.05

Egg Salad Sandwich

Exclude lettuce, tomato, onions & cheese.

Hamburger

8.45

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Exclude lettuce, tomato, onions & cheese.

6.25

Cheeseburger

8.95

Fried Bologna, Pepper & Onions Sandwich

Exclude lettuce, tomato, onions & cheese.

7.85

Vegan Burger

11.5

Vegan Cheeseburger

13.7

Seafood

Chicken Dinner - 4 Piece

with salad & fries

10.3

Haddock

with coleslaw, salad & fries

12.5

Shrimp Dinner (12)

with salad & fries

12.5

Lunch Specials

Two Cheese Pizza Slices, Pepperoni Pizza & 20 oz. Soda Lunch

Beef Taco, Fries & 20 oz. Soda Lunch

Add Extra for The Taco: Sour Cream (+$0.80), Double Cheese (+$0.80), Hot Peppers (+$0.80).

12.75

1/2 Cold Sub, Bag of Chips & 20 oz. Soda Lunch

Choose Sub: Select only one - Cheese Sub, Ham Sub, Cappicola Sub, Salami Sub, Assorted Sub, Tuna White Albacore Sub, Turkey Gourmet Oven Roasted Sub, Roast Beef Sub, Ham Turkey Sub, Turkey Club Sub. Choose Option for The Sub: Select only one - Sub Roll, Wheat Roll, Spinach Wrap, Garlic Wrap.

12.05

Cheeseburger, Fries & 20 oz. Soda Lunch

13.75

1/2 Hot Sub, Bag of Chips & 20 oz. Soda Lunch

Choose Sub: Select only one - Steak & Cheese Sub, Sausage & Cheese Sub, Chicken Finger Sub, Bacon Cheeseburger Sub, Cheeseburger Sub,Grilled Chicken Breast Sub, Pizza Sub, Royal Sub, BLT Sub, Veggie Sub, Fish Sub. Choose Option for The Sub: Sub Roll, Wheat Roll, Spinach Wrap, Garlic Wrap. Make the Sub with: Mayo, Oil

12.6

Burger, Fries & 20 oz. Soda Lunch

13.3

Daily Served Dinners

Haddock Dinner

With coleslaw, & french fries.

17.5

Shrimp Dinner

With salad & French fries. Choose Salad Dressing: Italian Dressing, Lite Italian Dressing, Ranch Dressing, French Dressing, Raspberry Vinaigrette Dressing, Greek Dressing, Caesar Dressing, Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing.

16.5

Value Packs

Two Large Cheese & 1 Topping Pizzas Special

Choose Crust for The Pizza: Regular Crust, Extra Thin New York Style Crust. Choose Topping for The First Pizza: Select only one - Extra Cheese, Anchovies, Mushrooms, Cappicola, Black Olives, Green Olives, Ham, Italian Sausage, Margherita Pepperoni, Bacon, Hot Peppers, Mozzarella Cheese, Sweet Peppers, Banana Peppers, Onions.

40.95

Medium Cheese & 1-Topping Pizza & 10 Wings Special

Choose Crust: Select only one - Regular Crust, Extra Thin New York Style Crust, Gluten Free Crust $5. Choose Topping for The First Pizza: Select only one - Extra Cheese, Anchovies, Mushrooms, Cappicola, Black Olives, Green Olives, Ham, Italian Sausage, Margherita Pepperoni, Bacon, Hot Peppers, Mozzarella Cheese, Sweet Peppers, Banana Peppers, Onions.

29.75

One Large Cheese & 1 Topping Pizza & 20 Wings Special

40.85

Large Cheese & 1-Topping Pizza & 10 Fingers Special

40.25

Two Large Cheese & 1 Topping Pizzas & 50 Wings Special

86.75

Sheet Cheese & 1-Topping Pizza & 50 Wings Special

79.95

Large Cheese & 1-Topping Pizza & 30 Wings Special

50.85

Four Personal Pizzas & a Blue Cheese Special

37.95

Soups

Soup

Tacos

Veggie Taco

Cheese, lettuce, tomato.

Pulled Pork Taco

7.95

Beef Taco

Cheese, lettuce, and tomato. 100% beef.

7.95

Kid's Specials

Kid's Chicken Fingers & Fries

5.65
1.5
0.85

Kid's Hot Dog & Fries

5.65

Kid's Cheese Pizza Slice & Fries

5.65

About

2.7 ( 10 reviews)
1401 Nash Road 14120
17166944799

We serve delicious homemade pizza, subs and more, made fresh daily highest quality and freshest ingredients. We are centrally located on Nash Road in North Tonawanda inside Jamie's Ice Cream. Stop in or call today, and experience the great flavor of The Wurlitzer Pizza Company!

Day of the Week	Opening Hours
Monday	11:00 - 22:00
Tuesday	11:00 - 22:00
Wednesday	11:00 - 22:00
Thursday	11:00 - 22:00
Friday	11:00 - 22:00
Saturday	11:00 - 22:00
Sunday	11:00 - 22:00

Cuisines

🍕 Pizza

Dining Options

♿ Wheelchair Accessible
🥡 Takeout
🚚 Delivery
🍱 Lunch
🍽️ Dinner

Recommended Reviews

20%

10%

20%

30%

2.7

10 reviews

Add review

😀

Mister B

2018-10-06 on google

Good pizza and stuffed hot peppers along with many other great choices.

😍

The Porg Authority

2018-09-18 on google

The vegan â€˜chickenâ€™ finger sub is absolutely incredible! I bought a couple more for some of my non-vegan friends and they loved them too - a must try! Pro-tip: Get xtra vegan blue cheese for dipping

😕

Jordan Reickart

2018-08-19 on google

They said this was a large

Add review

More Reviews (10)

Questions & Answers

Ask a Question

This is our "go to" place, but the past month or so, the order gets delivered wrong/cold, or it's skimpy.. The pizza was dry (needed more sauce) and like I said, the sub was not like they used to make...

I would call to find out. There isn't an extra room to have it there. You would have to find a place to have it or if it's a small group, do it in public outside or inside.