The Right Slice

Unique flavours + fresh made pie. What more could you ask for? Friendly service as well.

Made my wife pull over on the side of the road. Happy we walked into this little pie shop. Great variety. Purchased a slice of the island lime. It was great. Also picked up a pack of their mini pies. Nice to try multiple flavors. Very friendly ladies.

Yummy but small slice for $6.00

Their Lilikoi Cheesecake is so worth it! It really delivers that delicious passionfruit flavor that is hard to come by. Good crust too.

A delicious treat after Bubba's Burgers. My wife and I had the mini pies so that we could try 6 different flavors. So if them were delicious.

We stopped by yesterday because I heard they have gluten free items. We got a gluten free Chicken Pot Pie and one regular for me and 2 slices of Mango Lilikoi Pie. OMG SOOOO GOOD. We will be back. Thank you 🤗 🤙🏼

Best Pies In The World! Kind of pricey, but worth it...

I stopped by on my way home from Waimea Canyon and had a slice of passion fruit cheesecake that was delicious! It had a creamy consistency, was tart almost like key lime pie but you could taste the passion fruit flavor. It had a crisp graham cracker crust and was more like a dense cream pie than a NY style cheesecake. I highly recommend this stop!

Lots of variety, if you love sweets you'll love it. A little pricey, but very good

Was in the area today, stopped by to have a slice of a pie. What I could say, Macadamian nut pie was the best pie I ever tasted. Highly recommend. Will try to come back soon.

Best pie I had in my intire life, the mango pie is just incredible and they worth the detour

Little pricey but what do you expect for Hawaii. Quality was great though and it was a refreshing change from eating Hawaiian shaved ice every day. I had a slice of mango pie and it was awesome. It was made with fresh fruit and I could tell as my slice had half a mango in it. Their crust is awesome. Overall good experience and friendly staff.

Best pie place we have ever been to!! We visit every time we come to Kauai. And we visit more than once a trip!

This pie is SO delicious!!! We tried the lilikoi cheesecake and blueberry piña colada and both were out of this world. The lilikoi cheesecake was agreed to be the best slice of cheesecake we’ve ever had. What’s great about this place is also that the owner and baker is the one in here working the counter. She’s also got frozen pies for locals or visitors to take home, which looked delicious as well.Overall a really cute spot for a quick and yummy dessert! 🥧

This is the place to enjoy the best pies I have ever tasted. Just had the chicken pot pie. It was so good!!!