The Pizzeria

Great pizza place, very long wait time though if you go during peak hours. Like around 60-90 minutes. But definitely worth it if you have the time to wait. The square pizza with the little cups of spicy pepperoni is definitely the way to go, by far the best pizza I've had. Highly recommend

As someone who really loves a good pizza slice, I was blown away. I fell in love with the flavors, the smell, the texture, the crust, the sauce and everything in between. I get why it is so famous.

Best. Pizza. Ever.---Was recommended by a friend. The place is small and the line can go out the door. But the wait is worth your time for any given day! The employees are super friendly and their pizzas are fresh out the oven!---The pepperoni pizza is a must try. I usually don't like pepperoni, but this pepperoni is like nothing else. It's crispy, crunchy, and juicy all at the same time! The margarita pizza is also marvelous!---Definitely coming back here the next time I visit NY!

Very good pizza place! I went there and ordered their famous spicy pepperoni slice. Very spicy and delicious! There are little tables inside to eat at, but no chairs. I would recommend taking the pizza to go, as the place is always packed with many people. There was a line there, and I ended up waiting about an hours outside. However, the wait is totally worth it! Would recommend to anyone looking for delicious NYC pizza.

One of the bests ever pizza spots in NYC, I’m a big fan of prince street pizza. I cannot stop going to them! I love them! There’s either always a line or nothing at all, but worth the wait honestly. The pepperoni slice is well worth it!

Quality cheese, flavorful sauce, and a strong, not-too-greasy crust. Looks like all the grease went into the pepperoni cups, but I ain't complaining. Simply delicious. We don't find pizzas like these on the west coast, that's for sure.

Very good stop for a pepperoni square slice. Be prepared to wait in line for about 30 minutes no matter what time of day. If you can, skip the line and order a full pie. Very good but not always worth the wait in line. Try Village square pizza in East Village. Similar slice, no line.

Lives up to the hype. Delicious deep pan style pepperoni with a thick tomato and cheese sauce. Don't go during peak meal times or you'll hit some pretty big lines and DO NOT ORDER ONLINE. I waited two hours and my pizza never came. Delivery guy prob took it home for himself it's that good.

This pizza joint is the real deal! All the hype I read in the reviews are all concrete, howeverrrr don't take my word for it. You'll have to experience the great taste for yourself. My only recommendation is get there early. When I arrived around 2pm there was a line. Extremely great square slice with pepperoni however as far as overall taste goes, Di Fara's Pizzeria located in Brooklyn is still my top notch place for pizza.

If you're looking for a review to confirm whether this place is worth it or not read on. So, my first peice of advice is - don't go here hungry. You will (most likely) need to wait in line and that wait could be anywhere from 30-60 minutes. I was recommended the pepperoni slice and I'm passing on the recommendation because every inch of it was delicious...but a little tricky to eat. The one thing you don't to worry about here is your pizza being cold or not fresh, they're continuously turning over pies. Worth a try if you're feeling like a snack.

Was everything I expected! I was full after one slice but of course as popular as it is, when waiting on the line for at least 10+ minutes, you want to get your times worth so I suggest buying more than one slice to savor how AMAZING it is! Though the place is small, there’s places around the way you can eat in and grab a drink like Starbucks. 10/10.

This place is truly authentic Neapolitan pizzeria with very friendly staff and adorable decor. They used fresh Italian ingredients like smoked mozzarella (provola). The place is small but the food is great. Their fresh dough combined with the real wood fired oven makes their pizzas so wonderful.

If you only got time for 1 pizza place in NYC, don't make it this one. Line wasn't too long. Guy serving was pretty out of it though because he either gave my slice to someone else or just straight up forgot me and went to the next person. Definitely service issues. Pizza is okay. I love the pepperoni, but the pizza overall is just okay. No good place to eat and it gets pretty messy.

-No flop but a ton of grease from the pepperoni.  A handful of napkins were wasted on the pizza slices.- Cheese to Sauce: pretty even in terms of coverage but you will notice that there isn't much of both.  The amount of dough and the amount ( and spiciness ) of the pepperoni used set the tone. The slices do satisfy you.  You are getting what you paid for but not more.-Taste: Very good slice, get the spicy pepperoni Sicilian slice x 2. With the nice charcoal on the bottom , too much of the bread (while delicious) but not enough cheese and sauce will satisfy your cheese cravings.  Cannot skimp out on the premium ingredients when you are charging $5.20 ( including tax) per slice.  $10.40 total ( two of the spicy pepperoni Sicilian slices) out the door. Worth going to say that you have been there but not worth a repeat trip.

There was a line out the door, and for good reason. The pizza was outstanding. Small place but well worth getting food. Their thick pepperoni was the selling point. So good. Staff was also very friendly and quick. 5 stars all the way.