The Pastry Pixie

Awesome cupcakes! The turkey apple grilled cheese sandwich is delish!

We had them make a cake for our daughter's 4th birthday and it turned out amazing! She was having a "How to Train Your Dragon" party. We brought in little dragon toppers and they stuck them all over the cake! I brought in a picture of what I wanted and it looked almost exactly like the picture (they used fondant in the picture and we had them do icing). My daughter loved the cake and everybody at the party was talking about how beautiful it was. I would highly recommend!

I have been coming since they first opened a few years ago and cannot go anywhere else for a chicken salad sandwich or cupcakes. My family won't even order cakes anywhere else but the Pastry Pixie. So incredibly happy for them in their new endeavors downtown Neenah.

Amazing ...the 2 ladies working for my 1st time there were great it was my daughters birthday treat and they treated her great and made her feel special ...very nice on the prices (only went for a few cookies and a cup cake) ....the sugar cookies were to die for will be making this a more regular stop for my family

We just did our wedding cakes with the Pastry Pixie and were wowed with the results! MANY of the guests told us that the cakes were the best they had ever eaten!They delivered the cakes, coordinated with our florist for the cake decor (we topped them with fresh flowers from Sterling Floral in Neenah). They were even able to do a gluten-free cake for our head table.We had an individual cake at each table, and they were very accommodating of this request. We chose them because they were one of the few bakeries willing to make 25 cakes for us.I would definitely recommend the Pastry Pixie!

Great place for cakes and cup cakes!! Very friendly and helpful staff. They did my husband's 30th birthday cake. They did a great job. Can't wait get more cakes done from them for more occasions. Thank you again for making my husband's birthday very special.

This place is waaaaaay over priced. When we ordered my sons birthday cake we were quoted 50 dollars for a two tier cake in Dr. Seuss themed to feed 30. When we picked up the cake, the total was $145. Obsurd that they wouldn't even call to ask if it was okay that the price was double. Not to mention the cake probably will only feed 25 at the most. We had to buy more cake somewhere else. I got twice the cake for half the price from a professional in Milwaukee. I would not recommend this place to anyone, ever. Very unprofessional.

I have both gluten and corn allergies, and Ashley works around those with amazing results. From the brownies to apple pies, you are are absolutely missing out if you don't go here for pastries, and go often!

Delighted! I ordered several cakes, including gluten free cakes and cupcakes, for a big weekend. The cakes were beautiful, and all of the guests had glowing complements on how great everything tasted. I will order from here again!!

Excellent soup and sandwiches! My son surprised me with a birthday cake from here as well and I was amazed at the choice of probably over 50 flavors that they offer in a cake...not just plain old chocolate, marble, or white. The cake (pumpkin with cream cheese frosting) was absolutely delicious. I will absolutely be back and will order all my future cakes from this awesome restaurant/bakery. They are a true gem!

I went to the Pastry Pixie to order a homemade cake for my daughters baby shower. I was excited to hear the one of the owners has a Le Cordon Bleu Degree. They make everything from scratch! They told me I could go online, look at pinterest and show them what I want my cake to look like. They even said, if I wanted to mix and match I could. I oredered a full sheet marble cake. I must say, that frosting is perfect, it's not to rich, and it's creamy! The cake, they sure make your money worth it! The cake was thick, moist, and layered with that frosting It was to die for! I am not a big fan of that store bought thick buttercream frosting, I liked the whipped frosting but this cake everyone, beats them all! I will plan to go back for my next cake. Oh yea, they have the best cafe lunch, and the cupcakes are out of this world!