Tenuta's Italian Restaurant- Paddock Lake

We Just devoured the Family Special Spaghetti with meat balls, garlic bread and 4 generous salads! Under $19.00 and delicious. There was so much in the half sheet pan, that I have spaghetti extras for lunch and another dinner. Under new ownership and I am very pleased. I had only ordered pizza before, but now? the sky's the limit. VERY good VALUE and tastes great!!

We order from here frequently and the food is always excellent. Recently I ordered a pizza and, Instead of light cheese, got extra cheese. I sent them a message on Facebook included a photo of the pizza. They promptly responded, apologized, and offered to remake my pizza for me for free. When I called to order the remake Tony was apologetic, professional and handled it promptly . I got my replacement pizza and it was perfect. Highly recommended for their food and their service.

Excellent and friendly service. Delicious food, good prices. Pretty fast delivery outside of super busy hours

We had a Wedding rehearsal Party here it was perfect.. Food was very good service was wonderful. Prices are very reasonable.. Had a great time...

We ordered 2 pizzas. Stuffed and thin crust. Both were excellent!! People at counter were extremely friendly. The inside, behind the counter looked awesome. We are coming back. You won't be disappointed. Nothing like previous owners!!

I love their food and service. The family lasagna is sooo good and super convenient to pickup. Lunch specials are really good too, the garden salad is amazing, so many veggies and the house Italian is the best! Would definitely recommend

Pizza has never tasted better. Now if they would only make a true Chicago style deep dish, I would be in total heaven.

Great Pizza, new owners very nice. However my husband and I are older and living on Social Security, we miss the $7.00 PIZZA WITH 2 TOPPINGS, AND CHESSE FREE. would be nice if this came back. 😊

We ordered a catering combo - good food at a nice price... and appreciate our delivery guy!

Absolutely divine. I live in the Chicago-land area and this is still my favorite pizza. I look forward to it every time I am in Wisconsin.

I'm a Chicago guy at heart so I was surprised to actually enjoy the pizza here. I think most people who eat here are locals but I really recommend giving them a chance. I have also been getting the grilled chicken caesar salad, and while they use grated parmesan instead of shaved, the croutons oddly might be some of the best I've ever tasted anywhere. A very good option to stay away from McDonald's and Burger King at the intersection albeit more expensive.

Delicious pizza every time! Polly B.

Very very good place since the owner i stopped ordering before because the other people would upcharge my card without asking never complained just waited and now I’ll order all the time!!!!!