Tasty Pastry Bakery

When you need a treat, Tastry Pastry, has the best cake and cookies in town!

I had a wonderful experience with Megan. We placed an order for my boss's birthday and Megan was the most helpful a person could possibly be! We wont receive the cupcakes until July 3rd but I would imagine they are just as pleasant!!!!Accounting DepartmentDale Earnhardt Jr. Chevrolet, Tallahassee, FL.

This is my favorite bakery place in Tallahassee. They make perfect petit fours. The cupcakes are all wonderful and my husband loves the stuffed cookies. The asiago cheese bread was flaky on the outside and fluffy on the inside. The prices are really reasonable and the staff is very patient when you ask questions.

Really disappointed. No selection or variety. I can do better at home.

I'm extremely picky about desserts, but this place had a few options for me. I was pleasantly surprised. It's hard to find a dessert place in town that has lighter on the sugar options, and while it's dessert for a reason, I just wish there was a good go to place here with more whipped, mousse and chantilly options over sugary butter cream.

I absolutely loved my cakes. They aim to please and exceeded my expectations. Im a customer for life!!

The Tasty Pastry is Awesome!!! Great flavor and super fresh. Store is super clean.

My very most favorite bakery in the world!!

One of the best sweet shops!

Good co operative staff and very good pastries

I sent a picture of what I wanted and communicated only through email for my convenience (I work at night) and got exactly what I asked for and it tasted amazing!

Fresh donuts and bagels daily are the best things here. Come early for best selection. If you're going to get any of the desserts, it's best to order them rather than buy from the case. I ordered our wedding cake here and it was scrumptious!

The cakes are just “ok”. For a small town with only a handful of options I can see why people go here for custom cakes. It’s more of a old fashioned place with old fashioned pastries, cakes and cupcakes.

I ordered my mother's cake for her 50th birthday party from here. I came to them 2 months in advance so I could discuss my ideas for the cake. I wanted this cake to look nice. One of the employees told me I had to buy the supplies to create a specific design that we had discussed. When I brought the stuff in, I was greeted by another employee who told me that they could not create the design at all. So basically I wasted my money on that stuff. I had to keep coming up with different ideas and color options because they kept telling me that they could not create the ones I wanted. Although the employees were nice they kept giving me different information which was very frustrating and one of the employees actually gave me a name of another cake shop to go to. I was surprised. In the end, the cake came out okay and it was delicious but it did not look very professional. I loved this cake shop but my opinion has changed after this recent experience with them....

Thank you so much for making the extra effort to put snickers pieces on my snickers cake. It was awesome and my sons were very happy with their birthday cake! I really appreciate you guys!