Small Town Creamery

Delicious ice cream. Huge ice cream servings.

I highly recommend this little ice cream shop! The staff is the most friendly. The variety of specialty flavors is amazing. The candy variety is mind blowing. It's a visual party inside with all the fun items. There's no inside seating but there's a fun bench right outside to sit. There's free parking in the parking lot. It's handicapped accessible.

Sooo much to choose from! My family loved it here. The ice cream is tasty but the fudge? Even better! I have to note how friendly the staff was as well. We had a fairly large group and it was an hour till closing time. The lovely ladies working remained calm, patient and happy to help us. We will definitely be returning customers on our next trip to the island!

Tried the "purple daze" and really enjoyed it. The place smelled amazing and had some cool toy attractions like a ferris wheel made out of connects or a dress up area for photos.

I LOVE this ice cream shop!! In general, I can take or leave ice cream, but the flavors here are so appealing that it is hard to choose one. You can taste any flavor and buy a tiny cup or a huge cone. They also sell many flavors of fudge, another decadent treat! It is my all time favorite ice cream shop any where. It is always busy with customers of every age. Do try it.

Very cool spot !! First of it’s so cool when you walk in and see the ferris wheel on to the left (which was built by a 9-year old) extremely impressive. We were automatically greeted to try all kinds of fudge and it was impossible to make a decision (DELICIOUS!) the ice cream, there were so many choices and all delicious (we also got to sample any flavor) staff was super friendly! Fudge was delicious! And ice cream off the wall! Definitely recommend, will be back here every time we visit Anna Maria island

Great selection of ice cream and delicious homemade fudge. Nostalgic selection if candy and toys, and a friendly staff.

Love this place! Owners are amazing and the flavors are constantly changing! The fudge is homemade and it took me all I had not to eat a half pound by myself! Definitely a must on a hot summer day!

Cute place with a lot of variety and flavor! We'll be back most definitely.

Ice cream, specialty ice cream drinks, BEST EVER FUDGE! Fun selection of novelty toys

Sunday, March 8th @ 3:40 pm. Waited to be acknowledged for about 10 min . Said hello, and walked away. Talked to a customer and ignored us. Lost a big sale. Will not go back.

The best ice creams and a very nice owner. Kids loved dipped waffle cones

Visit AMI yearly and finally checked out Small Town Creamery! Great decor, friendly staff and FANTASTIC ice cream. Prices were more than fair. Line moved swiftly! 4 of us and spent less than $20. Highly recommend you check it out. Pic here is a coffee type ice cream I loved! We will be back!

We really enjoyed this place and would come back again! They have a TON of ice cream flavors, including some really unique choices (see photo). I enjoyed Trash Can (it had HUGE chunks of candy bars in it) and highly recommend Mexican Hot Chocolate if you’re feeling adventurous. My husband wasn’t wowed by the Cookie Dough (it was good, just not special), but he loved the Key Lime Pie flavor. The staff was friendly and helpful, and encouraged samples! We got the small town size, which was just enough for us. We didn’t have kids with us, but most other groups there included kids of all ages, and families seemed well accommodated. We also tried the old fashioned chocolate and peanut butter/chocolate fudge, which were both great!

Loved the Banana Split. The staff is very kind. Huge selection of ice creams.