Seafare of Williamsburg

This was my first time here and I enjoyed it very much. I ordered the crab and artichoke dip and it was delicious. The entire staff was very friendly and my waitress was as well. I went there on a Wednesday right around 4:15 pm. They open at 4:00 pm so this was a good time as there was only one couple already there eating before me. I would highly recommend this place to eat.

We came here to eat at 4:30pm on a Saturday. Only half dozen other tables were in use. Both my wife and I ordered different soups and both were lukewarm. The server took them back to kitchen were they got nuked. Main course was Norwegian salmon. I had special rib eye and 3 jumbo shrimp. My wife noted mash potatoes were salty. Again the server handled promptly and offered did side. My ribeye was cooked correctly. But it has gristle through the steak which took away the pleasure of eating it. Service was the best part of this meal. But it was not worth the price tag.

I ak giving two stars instead of one because I honestly think that they may have been a bit understaffed. But service was horribly lacking and it took over an hour from the time we sat down to get our main course which consisted of a piece of ham, couple slices of Turkey, dressing all smothered in gravy and some peas. It may not have been so bad for a party of adults, but when you have kids that are hungry and ready to eat, it just doesn't cut it.

Our party of fifteen was seated at two adjacent tables in Seafare's more formal dining room. Fine food and excellent courteous service is what you expect andget at this restaurant. I had not been to the Seafare for several years and wonderedif the quality of the restaurant would be maintained. The Seafare deserves and gets five stars from our party and me!

The food sucked!! This was our second time there after a few years and I see why we never went back until now. Our waiter was very nice. Out of the $80 we spent on our meal, the best tasting thing was the orange sherbet . I give this restaurant two thumbs down.

Had not been there in years. They use to have a fantastic broiled platter, no more. The crab cakes had more bread and fillers than crab.

Food was excellent. Veal was perfect. Stuffed shrimp was full of crab. Waitress very attentive, glass was never empty. Prices match the quality, if you don't want to pay real money for a great meal go elsewhere.

I do think that I have ever been so unhappy when leaving a restaurant. I ordered the 10 oz New York strip and it was completely burnt! It was chewy and hard to eat as well. I was looking forward to a good steak and instead was very disappointed. I had to spit my food out too! I also had to go back to brush my teeth directly after eating to get the disgusting burnt taste out of my mouth. And the service was not that great either.

Great crabcakes and jumbo shrimp. Food was fresh tasting and delicious

I have eaten here twice. Both times were big failures. The service was slow. They were really understaffed and they ran out of several items on the menu. I wont be back.

It was ok. We happened to dine here on Thanksgiving. Which should've raised a flag, but was willing to give it a try. We got the turkey special. Not all that. Maybe we should have stuck with their specialty.... seafood. Price was slightly higher than expected for the food served. The staff, however was great! If we do decide to go back, we'll try the seafood. Seating arrangement was a little tight. The atmosphere was good as well. If the cost was a little lower, they would've gotten a higher star. Happy Thanksgiving everyone!

Really nice upscale atmosphere. The service was wonderful and very proper. We felt underdressed given the surroundings. Our meals were delivered without errors and everyone enjoyed a delicious meal. The Seafood was excellent and tasted fresh. It was not very crowded the night we visited.

Excellent food, service and great locatiin right on Richmond Rd.

Nice ambience! The food is good but maybe not great. There was nothing really special about the food. However, the environment was cool and comfy. Kid-friendly too!Our waiter (Karen) showed professionalism and sure looked like she enjoys what she does.

What a nice dining experience! Beautiful restaurant. We were in the Cruising Room. Looks just like an old dining room on a cruise ship. Five stars. Food excellent. Service excellent from Karen. Candlelight, linen tablecloths and napkins, quality tableware. Amazing menu. They even serve sherbet before the main course to cleanse your palate. Top notch restaurant. Specialty is seafood. My red snapper was the special and it was delicious. Highly recommend.