Salvatore's Tomato Pies

If you're thinking about stopping here, just do it! The pizza is amazing and they a surprisingly good selection of beer. I will definitely go again when I'm in the area.

Always trying new tap beers. It can get a little cramped waiting for a carry out pizza. It is worth the effort. Best to call for pickup. Seating outside in the warmer weather. Did I mention that the pizza is great? !

We got the Forza pizza and the antipasto, both of which was very good. The service was great and Nathan was super friendly and helpful with the menu. Salvatore's is a gem and the Forza pizza should be called a Fiveza! (out if five)

Everything we've tried here is great, but the Forza is our favorite and our usual go-to pie. The market salad is always excellent too. Super fresh and properly dressed! Thank you Sal's!

Sals is so good. I didn’t expect the pizza to be as good as it Was. Staff was very friendly and informed us that we could get one pizza with two separate special pizzas on it (1/2 one type 1/2 the other). The fig pizza was very unique and very very good and will leave you satisfied. Our appetizer was fantastic too definitely recommend that as it was a perfect spice. What a fantastic pizza shop!

Outstanding food, service, and great atmosphere. It was perfect for a NYE date. We'll be back again!

Sal’s has our favorite pizza in Wisconsin. The crust hits just right, the pie isn’t swimming in sauce, and the cheese stays on pizza. Toppings are delicious and it’s nice to buy local ingredients. The beer is nice, and the prices are reasonable. My main problem is the size of the restaurant, it’s a bit small and the waiting area is almost nonexistent. So, it’s mostly a spot in the summer for us when we can sit outside.

Rad atmosphere, amazing service & even better pizza! The best pizza in Madison! If you are looking for a delicious gluten free pizza this place is the place to go!

One of my favorite pizza spots! They make some very good pizzas here and the menu changes fairly often, so there is always something exciting to try. A good selection of beer and a nice outdoor patio to enjoy!

I love they're pizza. Ordering is a nightmare. I mean, their pizzas don't take any longer than anyone else (45-70 min on a busy night) and they are such higher quality for a good price...but you can't even get in the door to order sometimes. Just rearrange how you do the entrance, please, everything else is perfect. Xoxo.

I absolutely love the pizza at Salvatore's Tomato Pies, so my husband and I used their catering services for our wedding reception meal! The pizza, appetizers, and salad were incredible, as you would expect from Sal's! However, communication with the catering manager was incredibly, incredibly difficult. I'm talking hundreds of emails to nail down basic details. Nearly every communication I sent required multiple follow ups due to slow/no response. It definitely was one of the more stressful parts of planning our wedding. Again, the food was really good, but I would recommend discussing communication with them before booking them for catering services.

Delicious pizza that's not too expensive! The outside seating isn't too crowded so on a summer afternoon it's awesome. Their local beer selection is great, with an amazing Madison-based rose cider that I tried.

On the plus side: Excellent pizza - really. On the other hand: Very noisy, very busy.So, make reservations, focus on the food.

The bacon cheese bread appetizer is amazing. Their build your own pies are a great deal with the happy hour special. Some of the best pizza I've ever had.

I had absolutely no problem what so ever with the food here, good thin crust pizza. However the food may be incredible but it's small and it's cramped, and quite frankly the service was a bit slow. Overall I would definitely come out to eat here again, the reason why my stars are so low is because I always believe in growth and if you put down a 5 stars I better be getting pampered when I get to this restaurant, I'm talking food great, service great, and have comfortable seating arrangements. Salvatore's has one of those and that's great food, service was a bit slow, and I was cramped it was a small restaurant. However I would definitely come here again. Also Dave Portnoy gave a weak score I thought, I find his reviews amazing, but his scores don't always hit the same as mine.