Rusty Jimmie's Crab & Seafood Restaurant

Was my favorite meal in the 4 days I was in ocean city. Great experience, server made us feel at home. Prices were great and we will definitely make it back there next year. Thank you for such a great meal.

Fantastic crabs and staff! We came late Friday evening about 30 min before closing so it was empty. But I imagine during the summer it’s packed as there isn’t a large amount of seating. But if you don’t mind sharing large tables with strangers - which is what picking crabs is all about! - then you will be happy. We got a dozen large and only about 1.5 weren’t good (too light or overcooked or fishy.) We May go again tonight! It’s small but the heavy male crabs we got were very very good!

Wasn’t overly impressed, just an average experience. $60 for a dozen large crabs was not bad but they were rather small and only a few were dense with meat. And the last two were actually mushy and I didn't finish them. The crab soup had good flavor but was entirely overloaded with beans. I've never seen so many beans in soup before, and definitely not in crab soup. The hush puppies were very dense and tasteless and were not like hush puppies I've had elsewhere. The steamed clams were excellent and the best part of the meal. Overall not the worst experience for a $100 meal but I would still call it very average. Extremely friendly folks, though, but I don't think I'll be back.

Good crabs and usually not too crowded. Went two times in a week because the crabs were good, the prices were good and the owner Chris took very good care of us. Chris is a waterman and spends his days catching crabs and serving those same crabs in the evening. The place is tucked away in Fenwick but definitely worth visiting while in Ocean City Maryland. They don’t have a liquor license so you can bring your own beer or wine. Really a nice little place and will be visiting again next time in Ocean City.

This place had amazing food and excellent customer. I love that it is BYOB. If I am ever back in Delaware, I'm coming back to eat.

Great spot! How often to you get served directly by the owner and his family? Not only to they serve you, they catch the crabs too! Everything is prepared to order, no getting half warm mushy crabs. The seating is comfy and the interior very nicely decorated. Was not too busy and we were able to be seated right away. It is a BYOB restaurant so if you want beer/wine you can bring it yourself. Very fair prices and generous serving sizes. We have another local place that is normally our go to for a crab dinner. After tonight’s meal and excellent service I feel this may be our top choice.I heard nothing but great things about the dessert bread- I was too full to any this time around. We will return again.