Red Tomato Pizzeria LLC

Too bad you close so early. Like you Pizza but always have to go elsewhere.

Good pizza and wing. And express service

Very good pizza and service.

One word for the pizza - BLAND! IT is not "New Haven style," at least not the old New Haven of Pepe's and Sallie's and the like. Like many of today's pizza makers, they don't use enough ingredients. The toppings are sparse, and they are not well seasoned. Also, they don't use SAUCE in their red pizzas, just crushed tomatoes, and if the tomatoes are not perfectly ripe and sweet, which they're usually not, you get a very bland pizza without much taste. Maybe many people don't know the difference, but if you have a pizza that is properly made with all the right seasonings and sauce, along with plenty of well-made and cooked toppings, you'll know the difference immediately. This place unfortunately does not make them.

I had never tastes their pizza but heard great things. I finally had a chance to get out after being cooped up for weeks during pandemic.... I finally get out and order a large pizza with 2 toppings... we were si excited. Smelled great... got it joke and it was so so salty...😩... literally we could only eat 1 and1/2 piece. Each the 3 of us. Had to dump. I have NEVER had s as pizza so salty and so ever cooked 😩. Such a disappointment.

Very cozy place with delicious food. Great service as well!

Best New Haven style pizza on the shoreline. In the winter time I go for the sausage and mushroom pie. In the summer months when the tomatoes are fresh I hopped 4 the margarita. And Any time and all the time the Clams Casino White is to die for. Fresh shucked clams!

Pizza was awesome generous on the toppings.

I went here 2 years ago their pizza tastes very good like Sofia pizza

Tasty, cheery, fast service!

Good food and very nice waiter

Made a pitstop from Massachusetts to New York to enjoy some pizza. One of the most delicious pizza i've had in a while. Definitional would recommend it.

Arguably the best pizza in Connecticut

This is a great little pizza place. It has very delicious and original pizza, I absolutely love the crust. The dining area could be better, but I can excuse it. I appreciate the family friendly atmosphere, and the accommodating staff. My family always feels welcome here. I like their calzones as well, very nicely made. I recommend this place to anyone visiting the area and wants some good local pizza.

Our family has been coming here for YEARS, we absolutely love this place. The pizza is fantastic and the staff is always incredibly friendly. It's a little off the beaten path and pretty small once you're inside, but I have never had to wait more than 10mins (and we usually come with quite a large crew). This is the number one spot for us to go to when we visit CT!