Sign in
Red Pepperoni
Recommended Reviews
4.8
Laura Campbell
Fantastic pizza! Love taking my family here!
Teresa Cox
Great pizza! Try the "chicken alfredo"!
Jeff Phillips
Tried the cauliflower crust pizza, which is gluten free, and really liked it.
tmshim45
By far, the best pizza in town at a great price! Tastes a lot like the old Sully's Pizza that was on Main Street years ago! ⤠Over 30 craft beers along with Fast friendly service make the Red Pepperoni the go to pizza place in Madison.
Marissa Mattingly
Good Pizza, Cheese bread, and wine they sell. Will definitely eat here again.
M G
Wife loved it. Artichoke dip was incredible. Pizza was incredible. If in the area, one must stop and try. It would be a crime not too.
Sandeep Raja
Best Pizza place around here. Cozy and comfortable, the food is so tasty that you will stuff your face with everything even if you do not have place in your tummy!!Do try this place if you live near by Madison. You will love the ambience and it's location just near to the Ohio River makes it perfect to walk off all the delicious food you have eaten at Red Pepperoni. :)
Lorene Gross-Norris
Pizza is astranomical and the service is too. Many different gourmet styles. We did a basil, spinach, artichoke, feta cheese with smoked chicken. It was superb! A definate A+ place to go in historic Madison Indiana
Chompunut Storey
Best Pizza in town. Thin crust is just perfect to load variety of toppings including vegetarian toppings.
Kathleen Thompson
Excellent food, service was great. It was great not to have to eat pizza from a grab & go. Love supporting local businesses!!!!
Mark Nevitt
Great service and awesome pizza. Our first time in Madison and the Red Pepperoni. Amazing craft beer list, best I’ve seen in a long time, and in a small town at that. I haven’t seen Lord Hobo Brewing anywhere outside of Boston, but here it was in Madison, IN. WOW!
April Marie Fears
The service is wonderful and the place is a welcoming environment. If you like pizza on the this side you’ll probably like them. We’re accustomed to a thicker pizza so that why there’s only four stars
Faith Schlatter
We tried four varieties of pizza, the artichoke dip and Italian salad. Everything was delicious. Great service.
Steve Junion
Ate here a couple of years ago, and decided to stop by today. We each had a Calzone that had a light and crispy crust - deeeelicious. And, the beer list is never ending!
Lori Potts
So worth the 35 minute drive to have some really good pizza!