Sign in
Polito's
Recommended Reviews
4.6
Jennifer Bailey
Good sevice. food came out right away. Love the breadsticks
Phillip Northern
I love all the food I've had there, especially the 16 pound stuffed pizza.
Brian Christ
Their website describes them as unfussy, and that's exactly what they are. This is a good place for a reasonably priced NY style pizza. The pizza is great, the servers are friendly, and the atmosphere is really low key. Try the vodka sauce!
Don Konrath
This place is awesome. Food and service are excellent. But be careful the portion sizes are generous! Rigatoni with vodka sauce is off the hook!
Brian Egick Jr
Always great, got a stromboli today
Bob Thomas
Great deep dish pizza! First time there and will not be the last. Wings were great with out food. Staff was friendly and provided great service. Highly recommend! Take the family and friends.
Bruh Soup
The calzones are amazing period.
Jackie Cole
Excellent service give them 10 Stars Italian food
Chad Geister
One of my local favorites for pizza and breadsticks. Good place to meet friends, enjoy food, and catch up on what's been happening in our busy lives.
Bruce Burgamy
The meat on my phila cheese steak was overcooked and dry.
John Kingsbury
The food is great. Try the vodka sauce! Beer in a hot glass doesn't get you five stars though...
Mead
Not too bad of a place to get a pie, but it can be a little expensive.
Mike Doran
Very good pizza and garlic bread. You will definitely be leaving here full and satisfied.
GlamMa Lipsticks&Lunges
Pizza was sooo good from NJ living in Indiana over a year now this place has the best pizza here by far the other places are good but this one was like pizza from back at home My boyfriend recommended Polito's he had the meat lover stromboli his favorite . We will be coming back again also great service.
Dave Pestrak
Best "Jersey Style" pizza in Michiana that I've found so far.Helpful staff to help me get what I desired. Thin pizza with a spicy sauce. To accomplish this, they put their spaghetti/marinara on the pizza. At that point, it is like home in New Jersey.They also have a "vodka sauce" that is quite tasty with their breadsticks. Could dine on this all day.But if you want Chicago thick style, be careful what you ask for. There are two types, and one of them is horribly wrong.Excellent place, I would highly recommend, even with my flawed Chicago style. The Jersey style more than makes up for anything they could do wrong.