Pizzeria Rustica

The best pizza, handmade crust with quality ingredients then wood fired. My top pick for pizza in the springs. Quant environment with table tops that you can draw on with crayons :)!! Pleasant and fun staff that are attentive. Lovely place for a date and fun eating experience.

What a wonderful night and superb staff. Oh yes, and the FOOD! I was blown away and so full it was hard to walk. Trust their wine recommendations... superb!

Madison rocked and provided great service. Had a great appetizer recommendation and kept my wine glass full. You must join me next time. (Sorry, it was so good, I ate half of it before I remembered to snap a pic)

Absolutely delicious. The crust is amazing. Some of the best pizza we've had anywhere (including Italy).

If I could give it zero stars I would!! Don't go there unless you want mediocre food that costs Broadmore price! My hubby, myself and our 2 & 3 yr old had lunch, Avacado Fries app, I had a French dip, he had a Burger, babies shared what they called a "pizza" we both had a soda, no substitutes no alcohol and it was 78$!! Then it wasn't even good, it wasn't horrible, but it wasn't good, and the babies took one bite and we had to feed them when we got home. It's sad that a local place opens up and the locals won't go back.

So it's late on Christmas Eve. I'm out running errands. My roommate calls me an tells me to pick up two pizzas they ordered for $35. We need to feed 6 people. So I get there run in side quick so I can pay an grab the pizza when it's done an get out of there hair.(it's late on Christmas Eve). On my way out I realise the boxes were really small. In those really small pizza boxes are some really small pizzas. Not enough to feed 6 people. So we asked for a refund so we could go an get enough food to feed everyone. Now up to this point I couldn't complain about the service. It was like every pizza place. When I asked for the refund the manager acted like I just asked him do do the hardest thing of his life and as if I offended him in the worst possible way.

One of the best pizzerias in town. Fresh ingredients, handmade pizzas.

Totally amazing!! First the place is cute. The pizza was actually the best I had ever had. The wine recommendations where perfect. James was knowledgeable. My New favorite place!!

We love this place. Amazing pizza. Very fresh ingredients. We love to come here for date night. Sit on the patio if available!

If I could give 10 stars I would. It's my favorite restaurant in town. We have been eating here since it opened. The food is consistent, well crafted and delicious. The staff has always been friendly and take good care of you. Come out for a date or with a group of friends- and enjoy!

It was amazing eating there, I felt so comfortable and at home! I’m German and I was able to eat a lot of things I know from vacations in Italy and it was real and it was authentic and it was delicious! The pizza is ridiculously good! Like original Italian good! The Tiramisu was delicious too! We had a mixed starter with Caprese salad which was really good too (to me the mozzarella is the most important part) and they even served (I think self made) pesto with it, which I finished by itself because it tasted amazing! The service was really good too and we didn’t have to wait long for the food either. It was all in all an amazing experience, it made me very happy and I felt better leaving the place than going in. It made my evening so thank you for all the delicious food you guys serve :) <3

We have had experience in dining at a fine neapolitan style restaurant so the opinion might be biased. The atmosphere was pleasant and rustic. The pizza tasted very good but some small improvements could make it great. The meat was poor quality and fresh sauce ingredients and fresh mozzarella would meet the highest expectations. We will come again when the craving hits but hope that the owner will take advantage of the abundance of fresh ingredients available to them.

I went to Italy a while back, and this was the closest to real Italian I've had in the states.

This was one of the best pizzas we ever had. The cheese is smoked for a fabulous flavor, the crust crisp, and the atmosphere cozy! We plan on going back to Old Colorado City just for this!! We got the cheese dip appetizer and it was worth it!UPDATE: We went a second time and it was again amazing! We tried the Rustica which was really good, and the special was a pepperoni and pepperoncino which was our favorite.

Great find!!!Since having moved to Colorado Springs, we have been on a search for a great pizza spot. There are so many great things about this place. The atmosphere here is appropriate for the name. The rustic feel makes you feel like you’re in Europe. The pizza was very good and the desert was delicious.