Pizza Suprema

Fresh, friendly staff & environment, fresh food

Disappointing foodI have lived in the area and always ordered from this place because the quality was pretty decent and close to my NY standards. Recently, however, I ordered a few times and the food quality has become poor. Today, I ordered calamari and a pizza roll. The calamari came dried and not edible. It was so tough, no one could eat it. I called to discuss and they hung up on me 2 times! I was shocked. Definitely won’t get my business anymore.

Coming from Jersey I was disappointed in FL pizza shops pizza and subs but the pizza, sausage sub & meatball sub 💯 amazing and jersey girl approved and I crave it!! All the employees are super nice!! Maria is always going above and beyond!! Willow Dr is your bigger fan!

Delicious authentic pizza. Friendly folks! Real old fashioned pizza artists !

Been here twice for pizza (Lg. Meat Lovers) during the Covid-19 pandemic. Very friendly service and great pizza at a great price. I had their Cannoli today, and it was seriously the best I think I've ever had. I may have to go back just for that.

This is my very favorite pizza place in town. This coming from a former New Yorker who loves pizza. They make a good pie that's for sure!

I was with a group of six and we wanted something fast. All except one got the slices and I enjoyed mine. They definitely seem more setup for takeout than sit down. Even though they were very busy they did a good job of taking care of us.

I have been looking for New York style pizza since I came to Florida in 2015 and a few close shots but nothing ever hit home like Suprema white slice to die for and the classic pepperoni pizza left me wanting more thank you guys for being authentic will be back soon

Real delicious Italian food!!!! Loved my meatball sub!!! The service was great as well!!!

Best steak sandwich around anywhere anyplace excellent

Amazing food, great atmosphere, and really considerate employees. Anything you need they help with. Definitely my favorite restaurant!

My husband ordered a pasta dish last Saturday night and I was feeling under the weather and I got soup. Omgoodness that soup was so good. It was beans and ham. This is the third time I've gotten soup from here and each and every time it has been amazing! I know someone's mother had to make this because it was made with love!😋

Awesome pizza. Lunch special always hits the spot. Get pizza by the slice. A little expensive.

Favorite go to for Pizza done the right way. If you are from the Northeast and want Pizza like back home, look no further. The only problem is deciding between a round Pie or Sicilian as both are excellent! Staff is always friendly and they remind me so much of Pizza shops from back home.

Thin pizza crispy with nice crust. Made me feel like I was in NJ again. Love this place! A++++ wont find better pizza within 100 miles!