Pick a Bagel

Awesome spread selection and fast service

Some of the best Bagels NYC has. Service is fast! Bagels are what it should be

Only 1 little thing (devil is in the detail) the lid, cheap easy to break. I had the coffee all over me when I tried to open the lid

Foodporn ! Go and enjoy with your eggs and cheese bagels !! Mmmm very yummy :)

This place stays busy but after a few morning visits, they have figured out my face and name so hand me my online order when I walk in. Their website ordering is a little dated, but it is cheaper than the app services like Ritual, and you have all of the options available instead of just the most popular ones.

Great bagel taste and atmosphere..

Breakfast this morning at Pick A Bagel on Lexington and 61st. I took my wife to spend a few days on Central Park. We were looking for a bagel shop for a bite to eat before spending the day schlepping around the city. We wanted something good without standing in line at a tourist trap-- and Pick A Bagel fit the bill. It's a small shop but wasn't too busy. There were a lot of employees and seemed to have a good workflow. Food came out efficiently and was on point. My wife had a ham and eggs on an everything bagel and I had a 'flagel' with egg salad. We enjoyed both. Coffee was piping hot. Overall very happy.

Great options!! Smoked fish on bagel is awesome!!

Rest good bagels and sandwiches, down fall is the price 17.00 for one bagel and lox’s this is not the four season, also when you tell them to not toasted they seem to always toast it.

The Pick A Bagel at 785 Lexington Avenue near 61st street has very large selection of menu items for a small store. And it is close to the 59th Street subway stop on the 4/5/6 subway line. There is a wide variety of bagels, salads, fish sandwiches, muffins, coffees, and cold drinks. And the wait staff are pleasant to deal with.

Quick service and there is 1 cashier that makes my iced cappuccino perfect

I ate a very good soup "Italian wedding "

Fantastic bagels. The everything with smoked salmon, avocado cream cheese and cucumbers is great. They have a huge selection of cream cheese options.

One of the better bagels I've had, ever. Pumpernickel with jalapeno cream cheese and avacado. Lavish with the toppings, more choices than I could process.

Great! Only bad thing was i was charged $11 for ham and cheese bagel. Ham, egg, and cheese was $6. Apparently the plain ham & cheese had more ham. So don't do that! Other than that, really good food.