Pick A Bagel

Hot-chocolate tastes like water. Wrong bagel, didn't add mayonnaise after I mentioned that. Over priced food.

We had been walking from Museum Mile and were desperate need of coffee and a place to sit. Pick a Bagel was a lifesaver location right in front of the train ;nice seating and good prices made this place a wonderful pit stop before heading back to Queens. The only thing we were bummed out about the seating area didn’t have charging outlets and the place didn’t have public restrooms. We survived we are New Yorkers and understand not every place Can have it all

Without doubt the best bagels in town. And the sliced lox easily rivals Zabars and others. But don’t miss the scallion cream cheese. Or the whitefish salad. Place is just great.

The bagel are too thick:( so much dough but the cream cheese was AMAZING

Pricy muffins, I would not mind paying $3.75 for a muffin as long as they are a bit better than average. Better yet would not mind paying $6+ for an Honest Tea and over sweet sponge/muffin IF it didn't came with a rigid uninviting customer service at the cashier...seriously, if someone says "hello" you should at least be welcoming, say hello back not just "anything else?!" With such rushing tone. Not even busy to be agitated. Sucks. Maybe should have tried their bagels, maybe muffins are not their thing...IF YOU HAVE TIME, GO ELSE WHERE PEOPLE!

Good bagel and lox i like zucker better but if you are close by get one

Winner of the World Series championship of bagels. Just kidding! Just another good bagel joint to obtain a meal.

The most over priced bagels I've ever ordered. $21 for a flat bagel + double turkey + pepperjack cheese + LTO and cucumbers and $10 for a flat bagel with cream cheese. I wouldn't go here again if every other restaurant in NYC was closed.

Only had a muffin there. Damn, was that one good. Crispy and soft, felt fresh. I don't know if anyone can make them better, maybe. But it was almost perfect. Also the bagels I saw looked very tasty.

Cinnamon raisin bagel with honey cream cheese.

Ordered the Nova Scotia salmon bagel with onions and capers. Received a bagel of onion and capers, i.e not what I ordered. Onions were piled in the middle to give a good cross section cut which looked nice but even if my order were correct it would have been a bad experience having a couple bites loaded with onions and basically none for the rest.Capers were very generous, but getting what I ordered would have been great.

We saw that they"re were giving free lunch for heathcare workers. When we get to the counter it was ONLY FOR LENOX HILL healthcare workers. My friends and I were so embarassed and left the store. Notice wasnt specific. We are also nurses though not from LHH we should also be respected as health care providers .

High prices. $12 for a sandwich:-O I noticed it after we placed the order:-(. But it was really good, nice and fresh! The only thing is that two different sandwiches were filled different, the turkey really well packed whereas the ham and cheese really poor.

If I could give this place 0 stars I would. I just ordered a BLT on an everything bagel, and it was so bad I threw it out. Let me start with the fact that is was so poorly put together, I could barely eat it. At first I tried to make it work, but the gallon of mayonnaise that they put on was making things difficult. The onion they used was barely even cut up, so the massive pieces of onion just fall out. The bagel was terribly so one half didn’t even have a top half of the sandwich. Cheese not melted, lettuce was all over the place and seemed as if it was put into a jar of mayonnaise before the put it on the sandwich. My girlfriend also had a bagel with cream cheese, and it was stale. The bagel was stale.I have been living on the upper east side for almost 4 years. This is by far the worst experience I’ve ever had in the UES.Go to Tal bagels if you want good service and good food.

Good experience. Little busy and the shop is small. But the bagel tasted really good. I wanted a bagel with all veggies. But the guy gave me bagel with veggie cream cheese. Almost same thing. But bagel sandwich would have been better. But the veggie cream cheese was delicious as well. I had that with 7 grain bagel. Would definitely visit again.