Restaurants near Peter Pan Diner

Bright Bay Deli & Caterers

"This spot has been my old reliable for decades. Very quick efficient staff and always familiar faces. Owner is on premises most of time."

Mulberry Street Bay Shore

"Place can easily seat parties of 4 or less. The pizza here is sublime. The flavor for the pizza is unmatched and their other dishes are superb as well like their pasta. My only critique is if you orde..."

7-Eleven

Takeshi Japanese Restaurant

"This place is a well hidden treasure. The chef is amazing and the sushi is fresh and like a piece of art. I highly recommended it. Make sure you try off the menu special roll called the JC Special. Pr..."

Victorio's Restaurant

"Very friendly staff an owner"

Dunkin'

"Fresh baked donuts. Fast service."

7-Eleven

"Very good store"

Bayshore Bagels Deli

"Bagels are always made perfectly. Spreads are always fresh. Been going here for about 2years. Owner is very nice."

Grace Deli & Bagels

"Great Food,the servers are very friendly."

Leggios Delicatessen

"Been going there 40 plus years.... Joe is the Best... always gave me a snack while waiting on line... Potato Salad is awesome too"

7-Eleven

Cyrus: Chai & Coffee Company

"Quality coffee and nice, knowledgeable staff. Huge plus that they always have non-dairy milks. I love how they have their tea and coffee beans out for customers to smell. They are all so unique and fr..."

Xing Wang Chinese Kitchen

"This is the best Chinese food place I have ever eaten at. The owners are super caring, they cook everything fresh and the food is delicious. It’s super suitable for vegetarian and vegan lifestyles...."

Subway

"Great service, great selection, great food, just sometimes you got to wait a bit but its worth it"

Crown Fried Chicken

Dunkin'

Baskin-Robbins

"Love my hazelnut Ice coffee, hazelnut favor unsweetened with cream and caramel. The best. You have to try!"

Khyber Grill & Gyro

"Love it! If you are a meat lover then this is the place to go. Their curries are served by the half kg and the food is delicious."

Exit 42 Deli

"Good place to go."

Khyber Asian Fusion

"I celebrated my PhD yesterday in this excellent restaurant. happy to tell that it was a awesome evening and the restaurant was indeed one of the reasons for this successful celebration. The stuff coo..."

Subway

Carvel Ice Cream & Bakery

Subway

Domino's Pizza

"This spot is great! Reasonable pricing, large portions and the staff members are constantly nice."

Rolling Pin Bakery

"The Rolling Pin Bakery created our wedding cake. I have spoken to them over the phone, through email and in person. All experiences were excellent. We were able to do a cake testing in the comfort of..."

El Pilon Restaurant Spanish Cuisine

"My first time here. I asked my mom and brothers where I should take my wife on our anniversary. They recommended this place and it was very much worth it. Although it was listed as Dominican Cuisine,..."

Ajs Grilled Cheese

"I love the Mac and Cheese grilled cheese. It was so good. Very cheesy the fries was good as well.... Crunchy and nice. The sauce was great too , I believe it was Ketchup and mayo and pepper and some o..."

Chipotle Mexican Grill

"Not much to say. Just some great old Chipotle. Kinda spacious, same atmosphere, clean, good service. Not much to say. Yeah I'd go again but it doesn't stand out."

Quiznos Bayshore

"I've worked at this store, shopped at it, worked at it again. Needless to say, I have a history here. One that sometimes was rocky but is ultimately excellent. The current staff is helpful and friendl..."

McDonald's

"The 5th Avenue McDonald’s in Bay Shore maintains their restaurant with high grade cleanliness and orderliness. The music wasn’t loud, the staff are prompt, serious hard workers with a measure of a..."