Sign in
Peace Pie
Recommended Reviews
4.7
Aaron Tummons
Good, but the sandwich style is too thick to take a decent bite from. You have to take bites on one side, then the other. The ice cream was okay, with the cookies being the best part.
Bob Ellison
This place is fun and funky, it looks like the name suggests. This is 1 of 3 in the country and a great asset to St Augustine. They make delicious ice cream sandwiches that also have a dollop of pie filling as well. The have a card called the bucket list, I have had the pecan pie and a few others. This is a great place to go on cheat day on your diet.
Jaime Hinton
Wow! So good! I gotta go back just to try all the flavors! Such a fun unique idea for a dessert on the go! So yummy!!
Darryl Dotson
The ice cream sandwich we had tasted good. We decided to share due to the cost ($6 each).
Elisha X McFadden Reformed Butterfly
SUCH A VIBRANT, GREAT SMALL BUSINESS IN ST. AUGUSTINE! WHO DOESNT LOVE ICE CREAM?; YOU GOTTA LOVE ICE CREAM, & PEACE!
Tracy B
Great customer service good prices and every piece pie is definitely made with love
Carlos Vargas
We fell upon this location while looking for another ice cream shop, glad we did. Lots of choices and all delicious!
Anthony Barchanowicz
We came here because of the rave reviews and Peace Pie did not disappoint! The ice cream sandwich combinations were exciting and very delicious!
Mike Freeland
So good. If you like ice cream sandwiches, this places improves on them 10-fold.
C.J. Bush
The ice cream sandwiches are unique and delicious. Slight pricey for an ice cream sandwich though.
Lynae Phillips-mitchell
The key lime was amazing!
Kathryn Waters
Best ice cream ever, and they have great choices!! I love it.
Cheryl Goldberg
No vegan options. My dog and my boyfriend shared the peaches and cream and they both seemed to like it.
MAYRA G Alvarez
Very cute shop with amazing customer service. If you are visiting St. Augustine, this is a must have. We tried almost 6 different flavors and they were all amazing! Mary Rose the shop owner was very kind and attentive. The shop is clean and pretty. We can’t wait to come back and try the flavors we missed.
Deborah Storlie
Very cute store and creative idea for a snack. The ice cream is tasty and they are quite creative with flavor pairings. The cookie is solid and holds the ice cream and pie filing well. I would call this a sharable treat since it’s so rich. It would also be fun to get two different sandwiches and share them so you can try two because it’s hard to choose just one.