Sign in
Paulie Gee's Short North
Recommended Reviews
4.5
Katie Doellman
The vegan cheese on this pizza is the only thing getting me through this quarantine.
Rachel McKinley Cheney
My group arrived as the restaurant opened and we were told there would be an hour wait. We put our name on the wait list and waited for an hour and thirty minutes before checking in to find out that it would still be a while before we would be seated. One in our group is diabetic and experienced extreme discomfort as her blood sugar dropped. We missed the happy hour special and were told that we would not receive the special even though we had been there since 5. We decided to leave and go to a different restaurant instead because we felt mislead and unaccommodated.
Ishmael Abdulrahman
Good vegan options, but sometimes the wait is long. Call ahead of time.
Olivia Rinock
Delicious vegan pizza with house-made cheese! They also have a great beer menu. Very friendly staff as well! We were able to get seated right away, even on a busy Saturday night. 🙂
Rocco Greco
Outstanding pizza. A warm and cozy atmosphere. Friendly and helpful staff. Great wine and beer selection. Highly recommended.
Ashley Martin
Hands down the best pizza in Columbus. Our favorite is the hellified pork pie white. The new Detroit style pies are a game changer. We <3 Paulie gees!!
Jason Yank
Great place, staff and wine!!
Michael Stiers
Loud but enjoyable! We are 40 Something's but love the food and atmosphere. Great food, attentive bartenders and decent service.
Christine Willis
A little too overpriced for leopard-spotted crusts that taste burnt. The topping combinations are interesting but wood fired? I’m not too sure about that.
David Brauer
Lots of my friends love this place, so I gave it a 2nd try. I've had wood-fired pizza that I liked a lot, but Pauly Gee's tastes too burnt for me. I understand the leopard-spotted crusts are their thing, but to me it's like eating pizza crust seasoned with ashes. Great drinks and wine list, though the first two wines we wanted were unavailable.
Kathy Apple
Delicious fire oven pizza with fast service. Has a nice atmosphere. Only disappoint is construction outside is cumbersome
Mike Pierce
Terrific NY style wood fired pizza. Great atmosphere. Will visit this place every time I am in Columbus.
Abhilash Bingi
The vegan supreme is the best vegan pizza I've ever had, hands down!
Brandon Moore
Our favorite restaurant in Columbus! Sadly we moved but every time we’re in the area we make a stop here!
jellytin
Had a great pie, met good people, happy hour specials were great! Staff friendly and attentive.