Paterno's Pizza

Incredible meatball sandwich with minestrone soup

For a bar the chili isn't hot, but has some good flavor to it. The pizza is delicious. Thursdays meatball cheesy bread sandwich is without words.

Home of the Incredible!! Need i say more?!? The best Italian beef if you love it cheesy! The chicken incredible is just as good! Love the daily soups and the chicken wings. The pizza is decent but I always go for the Incredible. Beef or chicken you can't go wrong. It's worth it!! Been coming here since 96! LOVE it!!

Good Pizza Full Bar. Great White Sox conversation when Sox Fans on Deck is meeting there. Say Hello to Murph. Tremendous Sox Fan!!

Their food is delicious!! My job is located not too far from the restaurant and I'm in charge of getting food for events. I have gone to them with large orders multiple times and not once have they gotten anything wrong. There is a weight off my shoulders when I know I can put an order in and not have to worry about something missing or the food not being good. I wish they delivered, but that is such a small complaint and not worth really complaining about. I suggest their food to anybody who wants good pizza and amazing service.

Love this place and da workers!

Good food. $2.50 beerz.

Loved the pizza! We ordered a regular thin crust sausage and mushroom pizza. For the place being so crowded on a Friday night, we got our food rather quickly. Now, there is no wait staff. You come in and order your food at a counter, get yourself a table and then go to the bar and order whatever it is you want to drink. Someone does deliver your food but other than that, you are on your own.The pizza came hot from the oven. The crust was crispy and the cheese gooey. My husband thought it could have had more sausage on it but it had plenty of mushrooms. It was yummy! So, four stars because the bar/restaurant itself is nothing to write home about, especially the backroom. Had that been the only place to sit, we would have left. Not a soul was sitting back there. Overall, great Chicago style pizza, but the atmosphere, well there isn't any. It's an old man's bar with very good pizza.

This place has a true old school chicago feel. The bartenders are great and the incredible beef is definitely incredible

Just came in town and been dreaming about an incredible for quite a while. I love the place

Great family-owned place, great company and awesome food no matter what you order.

Great casual place to eat and drink! Great prices with a friendly staff.

The beef is great. Has a true Chicago feel. I would suggest and come back again!

Everything homemade and delicious. Gnocchi was perfect. Little pillows of deliciousness, the best Eggplant Parmigiana in the city. Clam strips perfectly cooked not to mention the pizza A staple here in Jeff Park.

Love this little family-owned Tavern. Delicious food