Sign in
Old Fashioned Pizza
Recommended Reviews
4.9
Genci C.
Loveee the pizza here, good variety and always freshh. Convenient location and very friendly staff!
Aida Kapica
The best slice in NYC! i see some terrible reviews from people who haven't even tried this place all because Dave Portnoy didn't get to try it lol. Ya'll weird, try stuff for yourself before knocking it down and stop listening to others.
ardijana elezovic
WOW!!! I usually never write an review, but this pizzeria deserves one! I had the grandma slice and it was perfect! The sauce was so good and the slice was crispy . I am definitely coming back !
Rita Ndreu
Awesome place! Great spot, love the pizza. Soft and crunchy crust. Definitely would come here again. New favorite pizza place!
Floridona Mavraj
Super delicious pizza! Had the regular, lasagna and grandma. All 10/10. Super friendly staff also! Will be back soon. The name 'Old Fashioned' really stands true - the crew has been in New York City for 30+ years and the Pizza tastes like they definitely know what they're doing. Owners Nick and Dino are a delight... Super friendly and offered drinks and other slices on the house. 5/5 !
Nicole Perez
Great NYC pizza! These guys really know how to do pizza right and great service. Will become my go to local pizza spot
Eddie Alijaj
Great food great staff new pizza spot nice and small grab and go type of food
Manuel Soto Licona
The staff is super friendly and the pizza definitely makes its own name!
Hadar Ester Baranes
Great slice!!!
Kenji
Pretty good pizza at reasonable prices. A solid addition to East Village pizzarias.
Lindi Lela
Excellent pizza, excellent staff, large variety of different pizza, everything is so perfectly made! Love it! Will definitely be back again!!
Agim Krasniqi
Great pizza!! Go to pizzeria from now on! That buffalo chicken pizza is like no other.
Deniz Tufina
This is definetly the best pizzeria i've tried in NYC. The slices are great: tasty, big and really cheap. The most amazing thing about this place is the stuff, they are so friendly and make u feel welcomed. If u wanna enjoy some good food, this is the place to go, for sure i'll be back there.
Ben Qosja
Wow!!!! Giving out a 5 star rating for me is rare, but this has to be the best pizza in all of NYC. So many different options to choose from and One is better than the other
dm m
I won't be an a-hole and give it 1 star, but who's here after the Prez review?