Notorious P.I.E

The margherita pizza is super delicious. The first time I had it, my husband and I asked for sauteed mushrooms to be added to it. The next time, we just had fresh mushrooms added. We both agree that sauteed mushrooms are better. It costs $2 to add a topping. It may seem a bit pricey, but you get a lot of food since it's such a big pizza. They also offer pizza by the slice. My husband got the "Off the wall" kind and loved it. It sounds weird with grapes and cantaloupe, but it tastes pretty good.

Best new Pizza place in Norman, classic indoors with a Biggie picture to honor arguably one of the greatest rappers. Food, service and overall experience in restaurant or to go has been great. Crust of pizza and their red sauce phenomenal. Enjoy!!

Crust was excellent and I had a conversation with a chef? Owner? about their process of developing everything. Taste was also great, and portion sizes were reasonable for the price. Tried three different kinds over two visits.I was a bit disappointed about the topping/nutritional content of the slices. It was very bread heavy and not a lot of bang for the bread. Would have liked some more sauce, arugula, something like that to bring up the substance of the slices.

This is delicious pizza! Lovely non-greasy with a great chew factor, NY style. Can purchase whole or by slice. Also have sandwiches and salads. Highly recommend.

MY GLUTEN INTOLERANT BRETHREN, REJOICE! As Notorious P.I.E. has p e r f e c t e d their gluten free crust. It is fluffy on the inside with just a bit of crisp on the outside. It's not thin crust, it's not weirdly spongy, it's just like the real thing. It's beautiful and tasty, and heaven sent. (They don't have a gluten free kitchen so be weary if you have an allergy/celiac, though the staff does ensure you know this before putting in your order.) Waitstaff is so kind, ambience is so fun, and the specialty pizzas and topping choices are astounding! I recommend the Cheesmagedon, I believe it has eight types of cheese, one being goat cheese.. YUMM! Will definitely be coming back here for all of my pizza cravings.

I love this place. Tried for first time and loved it.... Kinda pricey but soooo good

It was real good pizza with a great crust. Atmosphere is a little like can be expected in a college town, but not unwelcome. The only bummer was that we waited for almost 90 minutes for our two pizzas. I'm sure this was an anomaly as it was decently busy. Will go back, but maybe not at dinner time.

Cool pizza place. While pie or by the slice. Great drink selection. They serve whole latte pie desserts if you are not to full to try them. Ashley was a good server.We have returned several times. Our new favorite is the margarita pizza.

Phenomenal pizza, great sauce, fresh toppings, the best crust. Wonderful atmosphere and good beer selection. Will be visiting frequently.

Great New spot with awesome attention to detail. I like the patio. Thanks for bringing pizza to downtown Norman.

I was going to take a picture before I started eating but it looked so good I forgot to take a good picture. The place had a really good vibe and decor. The pizza was great. I got fried cheese, big Peppa, and a cheese. I didn't realize the fried cheese was a slice but it was really good nonetheless. Just maybe not for sharing. The pepperoni was loaded with pepperoni just how I like it. And the cheese was exxxxtra thick. The crust was thin enough and thick at the top for grabbing. The prices seemed really affordable to me. These were all by the slice. Loved the sauce too. I will be back!

I am always happy to find pizza shops where you can buy by the slice. I tried the Big Peppa, which I thoroughly enjoyed. The size of the slice is just a touch small for the prize, but overall I'm a fan.

I like the decor and the overall feel... I did not like the 2 salad dressings I tried... but overall positive experience... very unique pizza topping options. I dig that.

This place is awesome. Crazy pizza combinations that are truly the best I have ever tried. You will love it. It's a relaxing/comforting. Definitely recommended, nice workers, great artwork, and well taken care of.

Really good pizza. Thin crispy inner crust with a big chewy outer crust. I tried the "Big Peppa" and liked it. I will be back to try more. Update: changing my eating to 4 starts because I went back and ordered a whole pizza and the sauce was off-puttingly sweet. I'm not sure if they just added to much, but it was definitely more powerful than when I went the first time. The sweetness was just to much. Still pretty good pizza.