Sign in
Myrtle's Pie and Cafe
Recommended Reviews
4.7
Teresa Gibbons
The pies are great we got pumpkin and silk. They are both really good. They have a (lot) of different kind of pies. Took home did not try there coffee.
Ann Marie Glaviano
Really wonderful pies of every possible variation, flavor ready to eat or frozen and bake off at home. Great treat! Very quaint atmosphere, like most of Princeton.
Bob Broad
The world would be a better place with more locations like Myrtle's Pies. I'm going to skip right over the pie, which is delectable, to mention the friendly and generously attentive service, the tasty coffee, and the decor which is perfect for this old-fashioned place of welcome. I hope you will do yourself the favor.
Terrance Kelly
The best pie and coffee anywhere. I cant say enough good about this place.
Sheila Bannister
Their French Silk pie is divine! It looked like 30 pies to choose from!!!! 💞 It's a must stop if you're in the area! And they have gluten free pies!
Ben Walker
Literally the BEST pie I've ever had and nothing else even comes close.
Victoria Hinderliter
Delicious, homemade pies!! Kitschy decor, served on china, super friendly service. You can pre order pies, select from pies on hand or buy take and bake pies. Excellent place!!
Amanda French
It was decent. I think I went in with too high of expectations and maybe should not have picked key lime pie. The Oreo pie was pretty good and my son liked the Apple pie. Good to try out once but may or may not be back.
Tammy Strub
We had been told if we were ever in Princeton to try the pie at Myrtles so we decided to take a little roadtrip to try it and boy it did not disappoint. Myrtles Cafe and Pies is a quaint little place with a homey vibe. We tried 4 different types of pie a 3 different types of tea. The pie pieces were large and very good. They have a very large assortment of homemade pies they said they make fresh daily and change out often. We asked if they made pies to order and was handed a very extensive list and told just give them an advance notice of what was wanted.
Michele Franklin
can you keep a secret?? This is SUCH a hard thing to do.. I'm torn 😩part of me wants to be SELFISH...I like things to stay the same, and this is THE REAL DEAL there is NO OTHER bakery that can compare. I SO want them to prosper, but at the same time, don't want them to go commercial. My mom would approve!😇 ⤠enjoy a leisurely drive, historic buildings and houses..and DON'T FORGET THE PIE !! you name it, they have it ! Mmmmm! pies vary daily, can order ahead. especially near holidays 😉