Milk Bar Williamsburg

I was on the neighborhood celebrating my birthday and I wanted a piece of the milk bar pie to take home But I got so disappointed, the size of thing was like the size of my thumb by the time I realized I was already at home.I’m updating my review since I gave this place another chance but it was totally a waste of money. The soft serve was salty for some reason. This place is all hype and overpriced. A total ripped off.

Small and straight to the point! Compost cookies, b-day truffles, crack pie and their infamous cereal milk soft serve! A bit expensive but although this is a cashless establishment, credit/debit cards are accepted as well as mobile pay without a fuss. Staff is helpful and very active since the place can get crowded at any given moment. Parking is virtually nonexistent and seating is too. Don’t drive too fast or even walk too fast because you might miss this little gem. Grab and go for a nice delectable sweet from the momofuku empire!

Soft serve was yum but a bit overpriced, I’d say the sweets are worth 3 stars. But service here is great hence the 4 stars

My S.O. and I were really looking forward to hitting up one of the Milk Bar locations during our recent visit to N.Y.C. We ended up choosing this one out of convenience during the last day of our visit, as we were heading out of the city. The spot is small, but the girl working the counter was really friendly and told us how to store our crack pie while we traveled. First off, everything was delicious, save for the compost cookie which was just alright (the chips and pretzels in it were stale). The crack pie was especially scrumptious, but I did think the slices were a little small. If 8 of those made up a whole crack pie, and a whole crack pie was $48, then I'm not certain I'd be getting my money's worth. All in all, I'd like to come back and try one of the other locations to see how they stack up, but I'm happy that we blew our last $50 on a bunch of treats.

Came with slightly inflated expectations. Tried the cereal milk soft serve and crack pie. Soft serve is nice to try once. Crack pie was definitely not my definition of crack, just a mix of sugar, cream and butter

Gwen at Milk Bar Williamsburg is a dream - super friendly and patient while my friend and I decided on what cookies and treats we should get. We left with a ton of different goodies, all wrapped up nicely as a gift for my out of town visitors. I love this location because of the extensive menu options, but more importantly because the staff is so accommodating and knowledgeable.

From upstate NY to New Mexico and back Milk Bar was my final and most anticipated destination this trip. It didn't disappoint but it didn't necessarily live up to my expectations. The cookies and crack pie are pre-packaged?? But at least they warm the cookie up. Crack pie was more like straight up sugar pie without distinguishable variety in texture or flavor between the crust and the rest of the pie. (I did eat the whole thing in practically one bite though.) Not as good as its reputation precedes but worth a try.

I can't get enough of Momofuku Milk Bar! Christina Tosi is a genius with both the sweet treats and the savory buns. I adore the corn cookie, crack pie, and cereal milk soft serve.

Two Words - CRACK PIE. But now they call it Cookie Pie 🤔. We live in sensitive times I guess? Should be 5 stars, but the location is small and the parking sucks. I’m saving that 5 Star review for the flagship they just opened on Broadway and the 20’s in Manhattan.

Delicious cookies and cake. Crack pie

Bucket list ✔️. Incredible Ice cream with cereal and cookies👌. I will be weighting like 3,000 pounds if I have one Milk Bar close to me! 🤣

Delicious! Quick too, get the sampler... it's the perfect mix of sweets from Milkbar.

Cozy place and good desserts. We went there at around 11pm and there was still line in there. We got the greatest hits which had a combination of their favorite dessert. Cake truffles are to die for. Also like their soft serve. Very delicious. Definitely going again and definitely recommend this place.

We always come back here for the soft serve, the kids/as well as ourselves go gaga over it. Cereal milk ice cream with corn flake crunch topping is lit. We also recently tried the seasonal pumpkin tres leches ball cake thing- Ah-ma-zing!

I came for the cereal milk ice cream and it was delicious! I decided to try the crack pie and it was just ok, it's reputation gave me the sense that I would have to buy 2 more after eating one. It wasn't the case. I did also try the birthday truffles and they were good but not something I would come back for specifically. I'm sticking with the ice cream when I come back!