Milk and Cookies Bakery

Not bad. Not bad at all.

More people should know about this place. The cookie sandwich i bought cost $7, and it was a lot of food. Im a large man. This is not a snack. The ingredients are high quality and everything is large portioned and well made. Quite frankly, $7 is a steal compared to other gourmet bakery goods in manhattan. The other items in the bakery seem more common and maybe more typically nyc-priced $$ (4.75 brownies) but they look good. What really sold me though, was that this place is in the middle of nowhere. A sleepy side street with nothing on it. There was nobody inside when i went. It felt like a secret. And the service was lovely, and so helpful. She gave a great recommendation. I found this location on instagram. It looks good, tastes better. More people should go.

One of the best places in NYC for dessert. I got the chocolate chip cookie with vanilla ice cream sandwich. I couldn't even finish half of it and it's only $7. So one sandwich is good for 2 people. Will visit as often as I have the chance.

Unreal good. This is harry potter’s favorite cookie shop for a reason.

We just managed to go there before heading back to Europe. When you enter the place you are met with an amazing perfume of freshly baked cookies. It was really an amazing little place. I wanted to find one of the best cookies in NUC, and I think I did. We bought the cookies to take away with us on the flight back home. We enjoyed them the next day in Denmark. They make really good cookies, better than what you get in Denmark.

Excellent place! Loved the location. Cookies were delicious!

Great cookie....a hole in the wall find

Cute spot. A little pricey but the cookies are good and a nice treat when you are in the neighborhood

Great atmosphere and wonderful baked goods

These are truly the best cookies in the west village, I only eat these cookies. Sometimes I have them delivered and sometimes I go and pick them up. I get the salted oat and the rainbow sprinkle. Both are perfect, and it’s good to alternate between them, eating one, and then the other until the box is gone. They are delicious when fresh from the oven at the shop BUT are also delicious to eat frozen. I keep my box in the freezer at home.

Been going here for years since it started. I've seen the business change owners/employees and have seen dips in service, but I have to say the product overall has been great. In NYC, it is the cookie that feels closest to being homemade. Reasonably-sized cookies are slightly soft in the center and is more solid to crispy toward the edges. I like they always offer a number of cookie types. My faves are sugar, white chocolate macademia, snickerdoodle. Definitely check this place out.

Where ma sweet tooths at? If you need your sugar fix you can't fail here. Grab a cookie or two, make it an ice cream sandwich or just go all out with a brownie sundae. Been here dozens of times and it's never failed me. I overlooked the caramel chocolate chunk cookie for FAR too long - get it.

A true hidden gem. AMAZING. and the staff is super friendly. One of my favorite dessert spots.

The cookies were decent, but the women working was fantastic! She gave great recommendations with just the right amount of sass, and if that doesn't make a cookie taste sweeter, then i don't know what does !

The kids LOVED the ice cream sandwiches. So many cookie and ice cream flavors to choose from!