Loading...

Mermaid Pies & Produce

Recommended Reviews

5
97%
4
2%
3
0%
2
0%
1
0%
5
38 reviews
😍
Martha Swanson
2018-10-16 on google

Great produce, friendly and helpful staff and BEST Quiche around!!! This little shop is a must stop. A real prize!!!

😍
Susie Robinson
2018-10-03 on google

Had the best Lobster Roll ever! Highly recommend.

😍
Tina Platt
2018-08-19 on google

A local gem!!!! Cuban was really delicious!!! Tuna melt Yummmm....... The peanut butter pie is the best I’ve ever had!

😍
Ryan Stires
2018-08-14 on google

This is a great little shop they have a small menu but everything they have is top notch. The Cuban and the Lobster Roll are great choices to go with a slice of there wonderful pies

😍
God Is Love
2018-08-09 on google

Awesome Pies and food. Super nice owners!!

😍
jesse ferguson
2018-08-08 on google

Best Pie I have ever had! You can tell the are made with fresh, simple ingredients and they knock it out of the park. While you are picking up some killer desert, you might as well grab a Cuban Sandwich with a side of pickled beets and you will not be disappointed.

😍
j v
2018-07-18 on google

Amazing lobster roll.

😍
Sandra Freeman
2018-06-17 on google

Love the peanut butter pie

😍
A M
2018-06-05 on google

The best lobster roll I have ever had!!!!!!

😍
Gary Shif
2018-05-25 on google

Stopped by for a little desert. The peanut butter pie was extraordinary if you love a ton of peanut butter. Vegetables were from local farm and looked much better than anything you'll see in your box grocery store. The staff was friendly and informative about the products and advised that the pies ate made in store. 5 stars for taste, hospitality and local stsndard. We will visit again soon.

😍
Lilly
2018-03-26 on google

BEST Cuban sandwich in town!! I Always get the spicy cuban with a slice of apple pie.... Great place for lunch and the owners are very friendly people :)

😍
Misty
2018-03-22 on google

I didn’t even know I liked key lime pie until tried theirs!! Owners are so friendly and knowledgeable, definitely worth stopping in!!

😍
Raymond Hodges
2018-03-09 on google

Great customer service very friendly fantastic lobster roll can't wait to try the Cuban will definitely be back

😍
Debbie Hill
2018-03-02 on google

Love the lobster roll and the key lime pie. My most favorite pie is the cheery pie. I ordered a cherry pie and got it home and i was disappointed because all others I bought had pie crust on top. This time it was the sugary sprinkle top covering which was too sweet . Disappointed but now know to ask before purchasing. Love all the food I have purchased and drive a distance to get to you so it is worth it.

😍
Darcy Frison
2018-02-25 on google

Best food we have had on our trip and we like GOOD food! What a nummy and fun little place. Chose this for my birthday lunch today and we are going back tomorrow before we head out of town.

Questions & Answers

Sorry to hear about your mother. I will be back when you are all feeling up to it. The best to your family.

They are open on a regular schedule. Call them or check out their website for their hours.

No, Andrea the previous owner sold the Sign of the Mermaid on Anna Maria 2 years ago. They do not serve her pies. They should, but they definitely do not serve her pies. TOO BAD!
Top