Madison Street Pizza

I love very good pizza

Very nice people and it's also very clean.

They just opened back up under new management pizza is awesome. Nice big and tasty. I highly recommended people to go there. They’re so nice and added so much good stuff to their menu

Sausage in baked ziti was burnt bitter and the meatball in it not good waste of $, pizza+Sicilian not too tasty this place is on its last legs again doesn't open Sun though sign says back in 5min no one shows. Place is for sale+for rent online. At least 1st owner it was edible but with this guy take ur chances 1star 😬 Revised 11.20.19 - went back to try last week+today the 20th, pizza better edible OK not the tastiest but much improved the sausage is better too, only has spaghetti no other pasta yet, still not open Sun, biz is picking up a little. IMHO I believe it's because he hired the little Mexican guy a great worker that's bringing the business in, sauce could still be tastier! Changed to 3 star

Great food and wonderful management. Haven’t had pizza this good in a long time. I highly recommend this pizzaria to anyone who wants a real New York City pizza .

I love the service and the product

I really loved the pizza slice that I had there and it was so big that I only needed to order one slice instead of two. I am glad it was reopened again because the other times I passed by there it was closed down but I found out that the owner was out for two months and that was the reason why.

Came all the way from Texas for New York pie! This was it. It was awesome!

If you want the taste of some good old fashioned Newyork pizza this is it. The Sauce is enough the cheese is yummy and crust is perfect. Did I mention my favorite part affordable.

Growing up in the west village where pizza shops are great!! This here is exactly the same!!! Love their new menu and new management!!!

Usually their pizza is good enough for me, if I do come here it’s to order a pie for my family .. but today I ordered a pie, walked across the street home and when I opened the box to my suprise all the cheese and toppings slipped off & ended up in the corners of the pizza box instead of on the pizza ?????? 16$ for soggy dough? Waste of money and time .

Great place good food, charming owner!

Every time I go there I'm taking care of promptly the pizza is delicious!!!

Nice folks, good pizza & a good price - $2 for a regular slice.

Great pizza