Lombardi's New York Pizza and Wings

Pizza was pretty good. 7 out of 10. The arancini ball was not what I expected but still eatable. Prices were pretty good. Restaurant is clean and staff is friendly. Good place to stop for a quick bite and not to spend too much money.

The first thing I noticed was the empty cannoli shells in the case - just what I wanted to see (they should be filled as they're ordered). We tried "the Lombardi" specialty pizza, arincini, wings, and cannoli. Everything was great. The arancini tasted kind of like a fried, Italian meatloaf, and the wings were meaty and perfectly cooked and sauced. The pizza was very authentic New York style. I haven't found a crust like that anywhere else in Evansville. The cannoli was as good as I'd hoped. It had a filing made with cinnamon and mini chocolate chips/pieces, and while I prefer it without cinnamon, it was perfectly done. The shell also had just the right crunch. Lombardi's has my vote for best cannoli in town, and the pizza is top notch too.

My new favorite pizza place. Who knew a plain slice of cheese pizza could taste so great.

Great tasting pizza, but not quite NY.First visit to Lombardi's. Not disappointed. Crust was excellent. Toppings fresh and plentiful. Sauce good, but not quite right for "New York" pizza.If you haven't tried Lombardi's, you really should.

If u are from new york you will appreciate the taste and texture of the pizza. I like that I can go in and buy a slice not a whole pie if u have not tried Lombardi's pizza u don't no what you are missing the food their is great and if you want something that is not on the menu just ask for Frank and he will do his best to accommodate you. BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA IN TOWN.

Okay, this is my first time having this pizza. Immediately I could tell the crust is perfectly crafted hand-tossed and made from scratch. The slices are thin, large slices with amazing taste. I've eaten at almost every pizza place in town at this point, and I have to give credit where credit is due, this is the best one. I feel like this style of pizza I've had somewhere before, I'm sure they were aiming for New York style as well. It's just a straight up taste you won't forget. Defines pizza.

Fantastic pizza! Rivals any NY style pizza I had. The cheese is very flavorful, topping seem very fresh. The owner is very nice and is happy to answer any questions. We got a half margarita and half pepperoni, mushroom, and jalapeño. We will definitely be back!

This place is the closest we have found to new york style pizza it is amazing my family wont eat pizza from anywhere else now! Great pizza great sides and great people that work there real nice!

Best slice in town, I go here all the time for a quick, delicious, and perhaps most importantly, reasonably priced lunch! Very friendly staff and the food ROCKS!

Unique taste aswell as very fresh food.. very addicting, absolutely loved their bbq boneless wings and pizza

This was by far one of my favorite dining experiences I have had in Evansville. The dine in area is a little small, but the food is absolutely amazing. Everything is made with fresh ingredients, hand rolled and made dough for all their products, and the Alfredo sauce might be some of the best Alfredo I have ever had. It has an extremely great flavor too it.Highly recommend their Stromboli and Chicken Alfredo. Both are exceptional and will fill you up with some to take with you.

Great pizza. Had slices ready to go like every great NY pizzeria should! Also tried the rice ball which was delish! Friendly staff.

First time to Lombardi's didn't know what to expect it had a good write up in the paper. Looked like a lot of carryout orders. I had a slice pizza and a salad. I liked the thickness of the pizza it wasn't thick or thin just right. The salad was a normal house salad. I will definitely go back and try some other menu items. The meatballs look fantastic and not sure about the rice balls but they looked interesting. Service was good.

The. Best. Pizza. I ordered Lombardis delivery through the Waitr app, and it did not disappoint. In an effort to humor myself, I wrote “make with love” as a special instruction for my large cheese pizza. The pizza showed up hot and ready with an extra pizza box? Not only did they send me a delicious large cheese pizza, but they also sent another one in the shape of a heart, FOR FREE. Lombardis, you are my new go to pizza spot. Delicious pizza and garlic knots. Great customer service. Keep up the good work.