Laurel Supper Club

Recommended Reviews

38 reviews
Chase Nelson
2019-12-26 on google

This is definitely the full supper club experience. I'd only recommend going here if you are truly hungry. Super nice staff and a good set of courses for whatever entree you choose.

Michael Pearson
2019-09-16 on google

Was there for a class reunion. Food was great! Our servers were very good too.

Ryan Dewitt
2019-09-13 on google

Great classic supper club Wisconsin style. Great friendly staff. Excellent food and drinks.

Jess Birken
2019-07-24 on google

Classic supper club experience. If you're here on the weekend and not having the prime rib special or steak, you're doing it wrong. Weekends - Make a reservation or prepare to wait 1+ hrs.Wait staff were timely and attentive. Bar staff know how to make cocktails - you're in Wisconsin so be sure you try a Brandy old fashioned sweet.Opportunities for improvement: the lighting can be iffy, ceiling fans at night create a bad flickering effect and if they don't have all the lights going it is too dark. But recently was there, fans were off and it seemed much brighter it was much more enjoyable.Still a five star review. Overall great experience, excellent value and you can't find this supper club style in many places anymore.

Mike Wolf
2019-03-25 on google

Everything was good, service, food, price. Will be going back.

Peter Peterson
2019-02-19 on google

Food was awesome waited two hours for table and we had reservations I feel it's not their fault people hang around for hours after eating but the hostess was seating us at a table for six then the owner give our table to some one else I felt bad for her but she said there was nothing she could do because it was the owner

Chris Terwedo
2018-12-18 on google

Truly wonderful Supper Club! Food was excellent and the service was great! Only problem... Food coma! Can't wait to go again.

Lannette Phipps
2018-12-14 on google

LOVE! LOVE! LOVE!! Fantastic old-school restaurant with awesome food and service. Lobster, prime rib, steaks...everything was super.

Donna Olson
2018-09-09 on google

Awesome food - the steak was the best and so huge that we took them home for supper the next day. Our waitress Maggie was also awesome - 1st thing she brought out to us were popovers with honey butter - they melted in our mouths!

Mary Bloom
2018-07-10 on google

Excellent fish fry! You won't leave hungry. All 3 choices were excellent.

John Lischewski
2018-06-08 on google

Phenomenal food and atmosphere. Really fair pricing.

Devon Davey
2018-05-15 on google

Food was excellent would definitely go back

Cathy Mosner
2018-03-28 on google

Family Christmas dinner. Always great food and service

Kimberlee Simones
2018-03-06 on google

Amazing food! Takes you back to a different time and place! A great menu and full bar! Love their Brandy Alexanders! I will certainly go back!

Arne Skatrud
2017-12-03 on google

My wife and I met my son and his new fiance and her mom and dad and had a great experience. They made sure we had the fireplace by our table. The drinks were awesome. My steak was very good I had the rib I highly recommend it. We have been at this restaurant many times in the past always great service

Questions & Answers



Yes they are have to sanitize when u walk through the door but food was good at any rate.

Currently we are only taking reservations of 6 or less.

Yes, I just hosted an event for 28. They have a really nice area downstairs for events.

Yes they do

I am sorry, but we are not.

Yes, we accept checks, cash or credit/debit cards.

Dining Hours are 3-9 Sunday, 5-9:30 M-Thursday, 5-10 Friday, 4-10 Saturday; if coming later at night, call ahead as kitchen will close earlier if there isnt business

Most items are gluten free - the only items that have gluten are our pasta or deep fried / battered items. Most of the daily soups are also gluten-free, but always ask your server as some do use a roux as a thickener. Most of our menu such as the steaks, broiled fish, ribs, shrimp are gluten-free.