Jimmys Pizza Cafe

I'm from New York, and with a last name with more than 4 vowels, you know I know my pizza, and I'm going to give it to you straight: I ordered a plain 16" pizza and garlic knots. Hear me out: This is not New York style pizza. It's thin crust. It doesn't have that chewy snap at all, and it tastes more like a bread dough than a pizza dough, almost like their proofing time was off, or the yeast didn't have time to do its thing. The cheese tastes like a mix between mozzarella and provolone, if not just provolone. The sauce is good. Honestly, if it was advertised as simply "thin crust pizza", I'd give it 4 stars, but I was expecting NY style and was disappointed for that reason. Absofrigginlutely order the garlic knots, they're worth 5 stars alone. Those things taste like they're right out of a NY slice shop. I loved them, and the marinara side was perfect. Their sauce is seriously very well-balanced. Like I fully expect not to wake up with heartburn. Lastly, I ordered at 4:30ish on a Friday, and the pizza got here in less than an hour. Delivery dude gave me a courtesy text and everything. In summation, the pizza is okay. It's better than dominos. Don't expect a NY style pizza, just expect a decent thin crust pizza with good sauce and okay cheese. They're not outrageously priced, their delivery time was fast, and their garlic knots were the bee's knees. This place will absolutely be my drunk pizza place, and I will likely order from them again.

Bomb NY style pizza. Love this place cause you can order by the slice and very good price. My favorite is the Quattro Funghi Truffle. I normally like meat on my pizza but this one is worth being a vegetarian for.

I was so excited to try their pizza!! Had the Bacon date and gorgonzola Pizza. I wanted to love it. The flavor was actually pretty good, but the crust was INCREDIBLY tough, likely overworked, and almost impossible to chew. Pretty disappointing, especially for $30!!