Gotham Bagels

These bagels are soooo good. So cheap, filling and delicious. I get the everything bagel with the Chimichurri cream cheese and it’s to die for.

The Original V sandwich at Gotham Bagels downtown is amazing! Your choice of bagel (we got everything flavor) with tofu scallion spread, avocado, arugula, tomato, and poblano pepper salad. It's very creamy and messy with just a tiny hint of heat from the peppers. The shop was very busy with all the Badger fans but the sandwiches were worth the wait.

Old fashioned bagle house nearby madison capitol.If you want to enjoy the diversity of cream cheese, this place would fit to you.Also very friendly staffs make guest smile.

Ordered extra cream cheese and paid $4.25 for a bagel. In return I received the tiniest bagel I have ever seen. It was like a little baby bagel with just a tiny amount of cream cheese. Some days I've had really great bagels that are large with a significant amount of cream cheese and then days like this where they are just unreal. Wish there was another bagel option near this location.

The bagels are incredible and the service is great. Highly recommend this place

We ate there three times in one week during out trip. It's incredible for breakfast bagels.

Omg best bagel sandos ever

Great bagel shop. Can't go wrong with a super egg bagel sandwich.

This spot has great service and enjoyable menu. One of the best restaurant in the area. The food came out fast and the prices were inexpensive. Highly recommended.

If you are searching out a good bagel be prepared to be disappointed. That is unless you’ve never left the Midwest. The cream cheese is not very flavorful and very skimpy. Expect to pay about Double what’s its worth and wait about 15min after you’ve order to get your food. Over priced, slow and disappointing

These bagels are the real deal. They are the closest thing I've found in the midwest to a real New York bagel. I think the only thing that could make them more genuine is the use New York City water. I love this place!

Amazing local bagels! This place is always packed. We love them. They have so many lunch and breakfast options here. Bagels are authentic and chewy. And the cream cheese comes in cool flavors like honey raisin! Staff is super great despite being so busy all day. Great experience here. You bring the whole family.

First of all, the sandwiches are fantastic. Fresh made, great ingredients, the whole nine. While I was there, people were continuously getting stuck in the snow outside and one of the employees kept going outside to help push cars. This probably says more about this individual than Gotham Bagels, but the fact is, they hired him. They're doing things right. Grab a bagel sandwich. Definitely worth a stop... especially with a hangover.

Best bagels in town, hands down.

Some of the best, freshest bagels I've ever had.